Locking in dependency is Obama's aim

I've been thinking a lot about Barack Obama and his tax plan. I'd prefer to spend my Saturdays thinking about college football, but since an Obama Presidency may force me to get a second job, well, here I am. Steve Charnovitz has a great letter today in the Wall Street Journal, commenting on the Journal's excellent piece entitled Obama's 95% Illusion. Here's what he said: Your editorial is very helpful in pointing out that Sen. Barack Obama's plan would allow 44% of U.S. taxpayers to enjoy no federal income tax liability. Such a policy is wrong in principle. If America is going to use an income tax to pay for the federal government, then all income earners should have to pay some tax.

Whenever any citizen is exempt from having to pay taxes, the untaxed citizen has little incentive to insist upon a responsible government. If we allow the tax rolls to fall to 56%, then we will soon be dangerously close to a tipping point where the majority of the public has no stake in insisting that politicians stop wasteful federal purchases and subsidies to special interests.

There are a couple of important things related to this letter that I think need to be addressed:

First, it is increasingly clear that Barack Obama's primary constituency is the non-tax payer. Because Obama's tax plan gives cash payments to those who don't pay any taxes at all, it amounts to another form of welfare. As the Journal points out:

The Tax Foundation estimates that under the Obama plan 63 million Americans, or 44% of all tax filers, would have no income tax liability and most of those would get a check from the IRS each year. The Heritage Foundation's Center for Data Analysis estimates that by 2011, under the Obama plan, an additional 10 million filers would pay zero taxes while cashing checks from the IRS.

So, Obama's plan is geared to increasing the number of non-tax payers. He is not trying to assist them in getting jobs that would help them earn enough money to pay taxes in the first place. Rather, by transferring wealth from tax payers to non-tax payers, Obama is actually enshrining a new and larger underclass -- dependent on government handouts for their livelihood. This is, of course, regressive. But it meets Obama's desire to make a large voting class permanently indebted to the Democrats.

Second, we are on a slippery path to having a majority of the nation being dependent on the innovation, hard work and entrepreneurship of a shrinking tax paying class. This is both unfair and unhealthy for the country. A permanent dependent class will be an economic burden and ultimately a killer for economic growth, because it will require new and ever higher taxes to support. What is the motivation for innovation if you know that 50, 60 or 70% of your income will go to supporting people who either don't work or don't pay taxes? How is that equitable?

It isn't equitable. And even worse, it totally ignores human nature. Multiple studies of welfare recipients have shown clearly that people want to be self-sufficient -- there is no pride in taking handouts. People want to feel proud about their lives and the work that they do. I don't believe that they want to be treated like children. The welfare reform of the 1990s proved that putting in place incentives for people to find work is effective. When given the right motivation, people find jobs for themselves. It's basic human behavior.

Unfortunately, Obama and the "well intentioned" Democrats have never understood this basic fact. The opposed welfare reform because they didn't think people could pull themselves up and provide for themselves. Their basic assumption is that we are not capable of taking care of ourselves. And now they are planning a system that will be a massive new entitlement program -- funded on the backs of those who get up every morning and go to work. It is destructive and will result in a massive new dependent class which society will have to deal with for generations.

Is this the kind of country America will become? A Democratic-socialist state with ever higher taxes and ever lower productivity?

This is the America that Barack Obama envisions. His tax plan proves it.

20 reasons to support McCain

(Denver Post, Oct. 19) Democrats and Republicans both have a lot to answer for in the mortgage mess. Yet one party is going to hold the White House for the next four years. Here’s a way of looking at the presidential election without regard to partisanship. It comes down to the caliber of the individuals who are asking for our trust, and the kind of America we want to live in. On one side there are the Pilot and Mrs. Palin, a war hero and a tough frontierswoman, a maverick senator and a reform governor. On the other side are the Wizard of Ob and his sidekick Jolly Joe, a Chicago hustler and a Washington hack. The Wizard scares me, because if something seems too good to be true, it usually is. Our country will be in better hands with the old Pilot flying. McCain’s my man. Twenty reasons come to mind, based on the rival candidates’ positions. It’s the Pilot for economic growth and job creation, for avoiding big tax and spending increases, for encouraging world commerce and preventing the return of 1930s-style trade barriers. He and Sarah will maximize America’s energy resources, traditional and alternative alike. They’ll restore prosperity sooner; no New New Deal for them.

The Wizard wants health care to become a government-sponsored enterprise, much like Fannie and Freddie, heaven help us. He’s against parental choice of schools, bowing to teacher unions. He’d sign the labor proposal denying workers a secret ballot. His ACORN allies specialize in voter fraud.

Pilot McCain would appoint judges who respect the constitution like Roberts and Alito, in contrast to Wizard Obama’s liberal activist judges. Rabidly anti-gun, the Wizard would trash self-defense and the Second Amendment. He’d muzzle talk radio with the Un-Fairness Doctrine. Saving babies after botched abortions is “above [his] pay grade;” so is protecting traditional marriage. Unbelievable.

The old Pilot’s wings wobble, it’s true, on securing our borders against the illegal alien invasion and refusing to reward immigration lawbreakers with amnesty or citizenship. But you know Mac will still fight harder for our national identity than the multicultural Wizard with his America-hating church background.

And speaking of Obama’s 20-year tutelage under Rev. Jeremiah Wright, who wants radical pastors like him and Father Pfleger as unofficial chaplains to the First Family? Not me.

A president able to say “God bless the USA” with no profanity or KKK sarcasm was never more needed than today, when perhaps 10 percent of a billion Muslims desire religious war for our annihilation. That makes Pilot McCain by far the safer choice to lead America’s war on terror.

The Wizard of Ob is such a naïf on national security, it makes Bush’s gullibility toward Putin seem cunning. Amazingly, he blamed the victim in Russia’s rape of Georgia. He promised an unconditional summit with the Iranian madman who wants to nuke Israel. He stubbornly insists on surrender in Iraq. He ranks below Clinton and Carter in understanding peace through strength.

This brings me, if you’ve been counting, to No. 20 in my list of reasons to prefer John McCain over Barack Obama for President of the United States, party labels aside. The final and most important reason is character. The crusty old Pilot, airborne for all these years, has it beyond a doubt. The weaselly Wizard may or may not. The shadows enshrouding his resume, the special effects propelling his campaign, just make you wonder.

Was Mac faultless as a POW or in the Keating affair? No. Yet his integrity is manifestly that of an Ike or a TR. Whereas about Barack, we can’t be sure. The Wizard’s voice is alluring, but what’s behind the curtain? These stormy days are no time to gamble. Trust the Pilot, America.

Plumb confused

Slated on Backbone Radio, Oct. 19 Listen every Sunday, 5-8pm on 710 KNUS, Denver... 1460 KZNT, Colorado Springs... and streaming live at 710knus.com.

Is Obama in some kind of time warp? Not only does he think he's running against Bush in 2004. Not only does he act like 2001, when Ayers said he and fellow terrorists "didn't do enough," is ancient history. He also justifies his "spread the wealth around" tax plan by saying it would have helped Joe the Plumber five years ago -- before Joe saved enough to better himself as he now has. Huh? We're talking about a guy who did save enough to better himself, by himself. What does Joe or anyone like him need with Barack's socialist confiscation and redistribution?

The Democratic candidate needs his mind replumbed. Backbone Radio can't do that, unfortunately, but we can help you filter the news, float the facts to the top, and flush the rest. Plug into our pipeline of principle this Sunday.

** My upcoming Denver Post column on Twenty Reasons to Support McCain will be Topic A.

** I''ll be talking with Aurora Councilman Ryan Frazier about the Right to Work campaign he chairs, the important Amendment 47 proposal to curb union power.

** And we'll hear from National Review writer John Hood about the money pit called higher education, which conservatives can start reforming no matter what happens Nov. 4.

** Plus another round of our Legislative Call to Action, the series we started last week with state Republican candidates. This time you'll meet John Hadfield for Senate, Ali Hasan for House, and other good ones.

** Plus a full hour running down all the Colorado ballot issues, with my recommendations on voting yes or no and why.

Conservative stalwart Steve Schuck reminded me this week that in 55 BC the Roman statesman Cicero wrote: "The budget should be balanced, the treasury should be refilled, public debt should be reduced, the arrogance of officialdom should be controlled, and the assistance to foreign lands should be curtailed, lest we become bankrupt. The people must again learn to work, instead of living on public assistance."

So our problems aren't new, it's just a question of having the backbone to face them. Cicero would have only withering scorn for the lies of Obama. Understanding what it takes to preserve a republic, he'd be with you and me for McCain, Schaffer, and all the Republicans.

Yours for the American republic, JOHN ANDREWS

Enough with the Euro-smugness

From east to west, living room to board room, Americans are watching a slew of disturbing TV news stories . The focus of the citizen is overwhelmingly on the economy and his or her own, modest and hard earned treasure pile. This is not surprising, after all the Dow is behaving like a drunken clam and the finance sector is as chaotic as a college department meeting. The media is constantly rattling everyone’s cages and our commercial breaks are now plagued with the most annoying ads known to man: those of the goldbug.

In the depths of an election the worry meter on many Americans is high. We all want answers to our economic question and, in general, want to see this country restored to a place of prosperity, power, and might. But across the eastern ocean, in the world-weary lands of Western Europe, a strange and different dialogue is bubbling to the surface. In it, the cause for America’s troubles is not practical or function but moral and the feeling is not of despair but strangely, of glee.

As the United States hits a rather large bump in the road, many in Europe’s chattering class are taking up a rather despicable tone. This tone, in the forefront hammers home the idea that America’s Economic woes derive somehow from moral failing, that her age of dominance is over, and that both are happy occasions to root onward.

Moral supremacy and the role as judge has always been a part of the European tradition. Since 2000, this proclivity has been primarily focused against the United States and Israel in discussions that usually, either, apologize for Islamic terrorism, lift up the European ‘way’ as just, or simply scapegoat America for a host of domestic European problems. Recently, full and front page articles have popped up in major European papers claiming that the age of American dominance is over.

Strangely these articles and comments come with, not just a statement of fact, but a moral judgment and indictment of American and her way of life. Quite often the words ‘redneck’ ‘bubba’ and ‘empire’ appear when authors mention America and her apparently lost power.

Moreover, in these periodicals there is also an obvious bit of smug cheer. That is to say, that Americans current crisis is not just mentioned it is cheered on with a form of moiling academic demonology. In these circles, somehow, the financial troubles of America and Americans is actually a good thing.

Such feelings and statements are as uninformed as they are vile. To state things as they are and point out fault is one thing; but to actually root for calamity and chaos is quite another. Moreover, it is quite self-destructive. An important fact seems to escape most European chatterers, that is, if America ‘goes down’ that Europe will not be far behind.

We have already seen this as European markets have tumbled in the wake of U.S. financial problems. In a more abstract sense, a removal of U.S. power abroad would force Europe to actually grow up. Specifically, they would have to actually spend money on national defense and foreign policy as opposed to simply relying on the ample subsidy provided by both the United States and NATO.

The historian or more mature reader can attest to the fact that such disruptions from Europe are not exactly new. For years, on many European College Campuses, it has been both fashionable and convenient to viciously assail the United States. Such criticism usually comes in the form of vaguely defined critiques of U.S. policies and or a bizarrely styled bit of political wishful thinking that is not founded in the realities of America or Europe.

Even further back it should be remembered that in the 19th century it was the keen desire of many European Nations to subjugated American foreign policy and behavior to their will and call. Happily this did not happen and it is important that it does not happen now. Listening to friends is fine, but doing whatever they say while they slap you in the face is not.

Unfortunately, it is likely that these academic and anemic voices will continue to blame the United States with the smug liberal tone of Maddow, Mahr, Obama and Pelosi. This blame game will probably disparage the United States for the global economic crisis without the responsibility of say acknowledging that Europe readily invested in America and made economic blunders of its own. This is a shame and will only hinder Europe’s own recovery.

Relations between Europe and America have always been complex and full of recrimination. I like Europe, I like their food, silly accents and women, and I also share their desire for close relations. But I don’t appreciate their chattering classes smug back biting and moral judgment. I’d also say that if Europe wants closer relations and wants to influence U.S. policy, it would help if they don’t constantly attack the U.S. with puerile name calling and instead replace it with a real dialogue.

The character issue

Not surprisingly, given Barack Obama’s meteoric rise in American politics–so fast that the people know little about him–John McCain has raised questions about the Democratic candidate’s character. But equally important, notwithstanding McCain’s far longer career, is the character of the Republican candidate. On that score, the issue is not simply one of Obama’s negatives but McCain’s positives. As we head into the last few weeks before November 4, we notice that the McCain campaign is publicizing the fact that Obama has publicly cooperated with William Ayers, the unrepentant Weather Underground terrorist, frequently over the last 10–15 years in Chicago politics and philanthropy. That is, Obama launched his first campaign for public office in Ayers’ living room and served with his friend before that on the board of an educational foundation. Although Obama repeats that Ayers’ 1971 bombings of the Pentagon, the Capitol and a New York police station occurred when he "was only eight years old," there is no question that Obama knew fully of Ayers’ terrorism. Indeed, Ayers reaffirmed this in a New York Times article, ironically appearing on September 11, 2001, regretting that he didn’t accomplish more in his violent opposition to America’s defending South Vietnam against its communist enemy.

Obama and his campaign staff regard the criticism of his questionable association as trivial at best and the lowest form of politics at worst, reducing it to "guilt by association." But there was nothing casual about Obama’s work with "a guy in my neighborhood," as he traded on Ayers’ political connections and was not in the least disturbed by the man’s violent radical past and his no less radical "march through the institutions" of the years since. It is entirely legitimate for McCain to question Obama’s complicity with Ayers, particularly since Obama’s soaring and inspiring rhetoric tends to suppress much-needed public skepticism.

It is equally legitimate for McCain to question Obama’s 20-year collaboration with Rev. Timothy Wright of the United Trinity Church of Christ, the man who was his pastor, performed his marriage and baptized his children. Wright has been preaching anti-American, anti-white and anti-Semitic sermons for years which Obama could not have missed. McCain has not stressed the Wright connection as much as the Ayers link, but the two associates are as one in their hatred for American institutions and our way of life. Doubtless McCain is sensitive to the bogus charge of "racism," even though Wright is well beyond the pale of civil discourse and has shown himself to be utterly incapable of good citizenship.

Obama’s claim that McCain has taken the low road, allegedly because his campaign has not gained traction and he is behind in the polls, is merely the corollary to his carefully crafted image as a sort of political messiah who will unite the country and solve the problems of America fully and finally. Indeed, he has said that he is the one America has been waiting for, the country that has so far failed to reach its potential, the country that his wife, Michelle, was proud of only when Obama demonstrated a winning appeal in the Democratic primary contests. It is wrong to raise questions of character, you see, with someone whose public persona so effectively suppresses public awareness.

McCain has been alleged to have a character problem himself, his detractors claiming that he lacks good temper on occasion and is subject to occasional outbursts. Unfortunately for his critics, McCain has disappointed them in his presidential campaign. But there is no denying that McCain is a man of passion and enthusiasm–passionate about his country and enthusiastic about its prospects for more good times ahead. By contrast, and this is alleged to be his advantage, Obama projects less passion and enthusiasm than careful calculation and deliberation in all his public appearances. He may raise his voice while addressing crowds, but the tempo is measured and, I submit, intended to assure all his listeners that the country has nothing to fear from his becoming the next president of the United States.

In all three presidential debates, viewers noticed more animation in McCain’s countenance than in McCain’s. These men, as Rush Limbaugh might say, "are what they are," but one can still wonder why that is. McCain is 72 years old and Obama is 46, a difference of 26 years. For a senior citizen, McCain evidently possesses a lot of energy. He cannot effect what he does not feel, so he is the genuine article. When he questions Obama’s judgment, his promises and his programs, McCain exhibits the genuine alarm that an honest man would feel. He wants a less burdensome and expensive government that protects the nation against its enemies abroad and violent or fraudulent predators at home out of a genuine conviction. He never shades his meaning and always says precisely what he believes.

Obama’s careful articulation of his, let’s face it, traditional liberal policies of big government at home and national hesitancy abroad are designed to conceal his true feelings. His concern for the middle class is probably no more genuine than Bill Clinton’s, who also promised a middle class tax cut that he abandoned almost immediately after he took office in 1993. When Obama calmly promises to "invest" in America’s future with huge increases in government spending on health care, public works and education, he sounds as if he were doing nothing more than pointing out, the way a faithful accountant would to his less astute employer, the costs of doing business. All that Obama lacks is a green eyeshade as an effective, but deceptive, symbol for his proposed raid on the public treasury.

But sometimes the truth comes out. It did, when Obama assured Joe, the plumber, who wished to buy the business and make more money for himself, that taxing people who make at least $250,000 annually shows concern for those behind him and "shares the wealth." This mild-mannered reference to income redistribution both removed the screen from Obama’s carefully cultivated reasonable image and handed McCain the political gift that has kept on giving for Republican candidates beginning with Ronald Reagan. Taxing the rich really means discouraging anyone from getting rich who has not already become so.

Obama has every reason to keep his enthusiasm, if he has any, under wraps, for nothing arouses the suspicion of the upwardly mobile American citizenry than pie-in-the-sky promises to spread the wealth which wind up lowering the general standard of living. Given his revealing common exploits with William Ayers and Jeremiah Wright, Obama is obliged to look sober as a judge. McCain has nothing to hide but Obama has.