Abraham Lincoln truly was a great man

In his famous Lyceum Speech in 1839, Abraham Lincoln expressed his hope that George Washington would always be revered. Little did Lincoln know that he too would be revered and that more would be written about him than anyone except Jesus Christ. Lincoln’s fame is deserved. He did not run for President simply to hold the office. Rather, he sought the office in order to deal with the nation’s greatest crisis. When the Civil War ended, the nation finally ended slavery, the institution that massively contradicted our nation’s principles.

Not only that, the end of slavery invigorated commerce and caused a steady rise in the standard of living for millions of Americans. Whereas the nation once had enslaved nearly half of its population and had provided limited opportunities for much of the other half, after war’s end it turned its energies to an industrial revolution that made America rich and powerful.

Millions of Americans admire Lincoln for his statesmanship, yet some on the extreme left and right accuse him of hypocrisy, offenses against the Constitution and even tyranny. These charges are false.

The black power movement and remnants of Confederate sympathizers would seem to have little in common, but in fact both have denounced Lincoln. Both believe that Lincoln didn’t really care as much about freeing Americans of African descent as he did in wielding power. Their common error, to put it charitably, is to ignore the circumstances in which Lincoln’s statesmanship was employed.

In his campaign against the spread of slavery following passage of the Kansas-Nebraska Act in 1854, Lincoln found himself in the middle between passionate abolitionists who disregarded public opinion, and pro-slavery men who were determined to spread slavery wherever they could.

There was no majority in favor of the abolition of slavery, but many Americans were determined to prevent domination of the country by slavemasters. This position was grounded in the judgment that slavery was wrong and, though too powerful to be abolished, must be prevented from spreading.

We need to understand that when slavery was legal most people were slow to turn against it. Lincoln walked a fine line in the North between those few who favored abolition and many more who hated slavery because it had brought Negroes into the country.

Lincoln contended that slavery was wrong because it denied the fundamental rights of human beings, and that its expansion ultimately threatened the rights of whites no less than blacks. Color may have been an excuse but it hardly limited the desires of slave masters.

Lincoln was reviled by northern Democrats for declaring in his 1858 Senate campaign in Illinois that "a house divided against itself cannot stand." Lincoln invoked that Biblical passage to condemn the efforts of slavemasters to make slavery national. He did not call for the abolition of slavery where it existed.

Lincoln did not originally support full civil rights for those held as slaves for such a goal was not yet possible. It was enough that slavery should be restricted to where it already was.

Fortunately, more Americans opposed than supported the spread of slavery and even more the attempt at secession by 11 southern states. While both abolitionists and Democrats wavered in the face of rebellion, Lincoln never abandoned his determination to preserve the Union or his commitment to the ultimate extinction of slavery.

After hundreds of thousands of Americans became casualties in a terrible conflict, it became clear to Lincoln that the war could no longer be fought simply to preserve slavery. As a war measure, as well as to propound a greater purpose, Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, which freed slaves in rebel states and thereby encouraged them to abandon their masters and even to join the Union Army.

Lincoln was no usurper, but he did not hesitate to use his powers to preserve the Union. When the Maryland state legislature met to vote for secession, Lincoln suspended the writ of habeas corpus and arrested all those who intended to take that fateful step. The loss of Maryland would have isolated the nation’s capital behind rebel lines.

As political philosopher Harry V. Jaffa has written, President Lincoln in dealing with rebellion exercised extra constitutional power to protect freedom, in contrast to Confederate President Jefferson Davis, who may have been more scrupulous but was dedicated to preserving slavery. That made all the difference.

This Thursday, Feb. 12, we should honor Lincoln on the 200th anniversary of his birth, for he well deserves the titles of Savior of the Union and Great Emancipator. He saved America for freedom.

Bad mix: Unions & health care

A friend of mine is a card-carrying member of the California Nurses Association. She is not a union supporter in theory, but cannot practice her profession at the hospital where she's employed unless she is a member. I spoke with her recently about a nurse that testified before Congress several months ago against the card-check proposal, saying she was harrassed and bullied at work by union organizers that attempted to strong-arm her into signing on.  My friend commented that she receives a magazine from the union each month.  She has often written to them to dispute an issue or present an opposing point of view.  The magazine has no space alloted for letters to the editor or forum whereby members can debate, or even ask questions.  Her union dues are taken from her paycheck and spent in ways she does not know and if she asks, her inquiry is ignored.  Her voice is irrelevant and silenced.  Her option is to continue or find another job at another hospital that also is most likely a union shop.  At 60 years of age, she is not in a position to give up nursing and pursue another career. In checking the website of both the California nurses union and that of the same organization in Colorado, there is a very different tone.  The Colorado website is professionally done and does not carry an obvious tone of hostility.  On the other hand, the California union nurse website is rather radical, if not almost militant about their support for one-payer nationalized or universal healthcare.  Their online store even includes the opportunity to buy Michael Moore's movie, "Sicko" and "Sicko" surgical scrubs and t-shirts.  My friend told me when "Sicko" was about to be released, nurses in her hospital sat at tables during the workday, handing out brochures about the movie, sold the t-shirts and veiled the entire propaganda campaign as being some type of health fair.  They did free blood pressure screenings, talked with employees, patients and visitors about the idea that if we are to be truly healthy, everyone should get onboard with a government regulated healthcare system.  The most outrageous part of this campaign came when my friend received more literature in the mail from the union, along with a return postcard which listed the movie theaters in the area that would show "Sicko".  My friend, and other union nurses, were urged to check which theater they would see the movie, along with the exact date and showtime.  This would allow the union to organize people to make sure each showing at each theater was sold out.  Their idea that Michael Moore is an expert in healthcare delivery was surpassed by the notion that if in the first days the movie was shown, it played to packed houses, that would create interest across the country, getting millions to go see it and ultimately buy into his notions.   The concept that average, hard-working nurses had the time and financial resources to put forth the aggressive promotional campaign of Moore's movie is not credible.  My friend pays about $1200 per year in union dues, but she feels much of that goes toward an ongoing mass mailing and workplace literature distribution regarding the different political policies they promote.  Where did all the money needed to try and send Moore's movie to the top of the ratings come from? 

California nurses union officials are in a brutal war of words with the powerful SEIU (Service Employees International Union.   Frankly, any connection between the words, "union" and "international" in our country gives me reason to fear. ) The SEIU is on the march with their own unionized agenda, attempting to sign up other hospital workers such as nurse aids, medical tech personnel, maintenance, housekeeping and food service workers.  The SEIU endorsed Obama for the presidency and funneled significant amounts of money into his campaign.  The California nurses union is fearful that the SEIU will be able to siphon off some union nurses into their organization.  

Will the radical agenda and determination to drive policy and shape delivery of care as seen in the California model spread East?  There is a strong movement to do just that. They are outspoken in their criticism for the current stimulus plan, as it does not give them the desire of their hearts--government controlled delivery of healthcare ASAP.  They are calling for a plan entitled, "Medicare for All". They believe every American, regardless of age or ability to pay or not pay, should be signed up for this new Medicare plan which would be operated in much the same fashion as the one we already have that is a bankrupt ticking time bomb about to go off, plunging us further into the morass of eternal debt and obligation.

 In promoting the new Medicare plan, the nurses don't explain how they intend to pay off and clean up the current Medicare nightmare.  One of their current mantra's is that the government needs to fix healthcare, for in doing so, that is the last best medicine for the economy as a whole. These folks also don't discuss their plan to solve the huge debt obligation California carries within it's Medicaid system. Millions upon millions continue to be spent around the country, California in particular, for health services dedicated to the care of persons in this country illegally. As for that issue, the California nurses union believes ALL persons should have full access to every type and style of healthcare in our country. Additionally, nurses should be able to demand through their union whatever salary they believe to be fair and have that amount paid. They believe the culprits in our healthcare system are hospitals, insurance companies and pharmaceutical companies. Any attempt by those three industries to break even or make a profit is wrong and greedy.  It is only the nurses that are to be paid and profit at their desired level, and patients that should be given all healthcare services at little to preferably, no cost. 

Those in our families, circle of friends and communities that believe there is "free" healthcare waiting for them if only this particular stimulus package is passed are in for a sudden and rude awakening. If our healthcare is moving toward a system that is completely taken over by unions that actually believe Michael Moore is an authoritative voice regarding our care, may Heaven help the rest of us.

Give the Senate a shout out

Here are email addresses for over 500 staff contacts in US Senate offices in Washington DC. Let's make our voices heard in opposition to the "stimulus" bill that will do so little for our prosperity and so much TO our liberty. ==================================

SAY NO TO THE PORK BILL CONTACT THEM ALL

Note: These are listed alphabetically by staffers' first names. If your email browser permits, send to all of them. If you want to pull out by a specific Senator's office, copy into Word and search by that individual's last name.

aaron_mckay@grassley.senate.gov, aaron_saunders@landrieu.senate.gov, aaron_whitesel@lugar.senate.gov, Adam_Brake@LGraham.senate.gov, Adam_Howard@mcconnell.senate.gov, adam_noah@chambliss.senate.gov, adam_sharp@landrieu.senate.gov, Adelle_Cruz@reid.senate.gov, alan_hanson@sessions.senate.gov, alan_hanson@shelby.senate.gov, alex_swartsel@whitehouse.senate.gov, Alexander_McDonough@reid.senate.gov, Alice_Yates@levin.senate.gov, alison_pascale@levin.senate.gov, alison_warner@levin.senate.gov, allison_thompson@mcconnell.senate.gov, althea_stmartin@murkowski.senate.gov, amanda_clausen@begich.senate.gov, amanda_makki@murkowski.senate.gov, amanda_renteria@stabenow.senate.gov, amber_sechrist@bennett.senate.gov, amy_murray@harkin.senate.gov, Andre_Harper@Voinovich.senate.gov, andrea_mokros@klobuchar.senate.gov, andrew_grobmyer@pryor.senate.gov, andrew_person@baucus.senate.gov, andrew_wilder@kyl.senate.gov, andy_fisher@lugar.senate.gov, andy_fisher@lugar.senate.gov, andy_martin@klobuchar.senate.gov, andy_york@pryor.senate.gov, Angela_Mikolajewski@Voinovich.senate.gov, Angela_Youngen@Voinovich.senate.gov, angeline_macaspac@feinstein.senate.gov, ann_begeman@mccain.senate.gov, ann_norris@boxer.senate.gov, Anna_Levin@snowe.senate.gov, anna_taylor@lincoln.senate.gov, anne_caldwell@shelby.senate.gov, appropriations@martinez.senate.gov, arne_fuglvog@murkowski.senate.gov, ashley_ridlon@lincoln.senate.gov, ben_weiner@whitehouse.senate.gov, Ben_Widness@wyden.senate.gov, Beth_Hansen@Voinovich.senate.gov, Beth_Martens@Voinovich.senate.gov, beth_osborne@carper.senate.gov, beth_pellett_levine@grassley.senate.gov, Betty_Burger@Grassley.senate.gov, bev_schroeder@harkin.senate.gov, bill_ghent@carper.senate.gov, bill_lombardi@tester.senate.gov, bill_nelson@billnelson.senate.gov, Blair_Hinderliter@reid.senate.gov, bob_russell@pryor.senate.gov, brad_crowell@whitehouse.senate.gov, Brandon_willis@baucus.senate.gov, brendan_plack@thune.senate.gov, Bret_Bernhardt@demint.senate.gov, brian_hart@brownback.senate.gov, brian_mckeon@boxer.senate.gov, brian_robertson@brownback.senate.gov, Brian_Weiss@bayh.senate.gov, Brianne_Rogers@baucus.senate.gov, brianne_rogers@baucus.senate.gov, bridget_petruczok@boxer.senate.gov, Bridget_Walsh@tester.senate.gov, Brittany_Blanchard@reid.senate.gov, brownback@brownback.senate.gov, brydon_ross@martinez.senate.gov, brydon_ross@martinez.senate.gov, Bryn_McDonough@casey.senate.gov, bulletinfeedback@boxer.senate.gov, carbonbuster@klobuchar.senate.gov, carina_armenta@boxer.senate.gov, casework@grassley.senate.gov, Catherine_Henson@isakson.senate.gov, charlie_salem@bayh.senate.gov, Charvez_Foger@reid.senate.gov, chris_adamo@stabenow.senate.gov, chris_carr@isakson.senate.gov, chris_homan@durbin.senate.gov, Chris_Lanen@reed.senate.gov, chris_murray@bayh.senate.gov, Chris_Paulitz@Voinovich.senate.gov, chris_prendergast@carper.senate.gov, chris_thompson@feinstein.senate.gov, christiana_gallagher@bennelson.senate.gov, Christina_Martinez@reid.senate.gov, Christina_mulka@durbin.senate.gov, Christopher_Bradish@specter.senate.gov, christopher_day@billnelson.senate.gov, chuck_grassley@grassley.senate.gov, chuck_kleeschulte@murkowski.senate.gov, cictor_cervino@martinez.senate.gov, clarine_nardi_riddle@lieberman.senate.gov, clay_currey@sessions.senate.gov, Colin_Allen@LGraham.senate.gov, colleen_briggs@stabenow.senate.gov, colleen_briggs@stabenow.senate.gov, corene_ashley@specter.senate.gov, Courtney_Shadegg@Coburn.senate.gov, craig_ferguson@crapo.senate.gov, craig_wismer@kyl.senate.gov, ctrx4change@dodd.senate.gov, cynthia_bartel@johnson.senate.gov, Cynthia_Walker@Bayh.senate.gov, Daffnei_Riedel@thune.senate.gov, dan_mclaughlin@billnelson.senate.gov, Dana_Smullen@Voinovich.senate.gov, Danica_Daneshforouz@reid.senate.gov, darcie_tokioka@akaka.senate.gov, david_blair@wyden.senate.gov, david_cobb@baucus.senate.gov, David_Kronig@dodd.senate.gov, david_lazarus@durbin.senate.gov, david_lyles@levin.senate.gov, david_quinalty@ensign.senate.gov, David_Wade@kerry.senate.gov, david_young@grassley.senate.gov, Dayle_Williamson@bennelson.senate.gov, DCIntern4@klobuchar.senate.gov, Deborah_calvert@klobuchar.senate.gov, deran_atamian@feinstein.senate.gov, donalyn_delacruz@akaka.senate.gov, Drey_Samuelson@johnson.senate.gov, ed_french@lincoln.senate.gov, elissa.scannell@mail.house.gov, Eliz_King@reed.senate.gov, elizabeth_burks@lincoln.senate.gov, elizabeth_maier@kyl.senate.gov, Elizabeth_reed@levin.senate.gov, ellen_cahill@mccain.senate.gov, Ellen_Kinker@Voinovich.senate.gov, elyse_wasch@reed.senate.gov, energy@lugar.senate.gov, energy_prices@crapo.senate.gov, Eric_Hinten@Voinovich.senate.gov, Eric_Kleiman@bayh.senate.gov, Eric_Mogilnicki@kennedy.senate.gov, Erik_Johnson@Voinovich.senate.gov, erin_barry@johnson.senate.gov, Erin_Walls@carper.senate.gov, frank_rowe@lieberman.senate.gov, Fred_Karem@mcconnell.senate.gov, gabe_schneider@levin.senate.gov, Galen_Roehl@Brownback.senate.gov, Garrette_Silverman@Voinovich.senate.gov, Gary_Myrick@reid.senate.gov, Gavin_Parke@reid.senate.gov, gayle_mills@specter.senate.gov, george_callas@voinovich.senate.gov, georgiana_reynal@lugar.senate.gov, glee_smith@isakson.senate.gov, glen_chambers@brownback.senate.gov, Greg_bohrer@klobuchar.senate.gov, greg_chaney@stabenow.senate.gov, greg_gross@dole.senate.gov, gregg_richard@crapo.senate.gov, Hannah_Benton@mcconnell.senate.gov, hannah_herdlinger@pryor.senate.gov, hap_rigby@demint.senate.gov, healthsummit@klobuchar.senate.gov, Heather_Homan@Voinovich.senate.gov, Holly_Nesbit@collins.senate.gov, Holly_santry@bunning.senate.gov, Ida_Gaines@reid.senate.gov, Ileanexis_Deese@reid.senate.gov, inauguration@dodd.senate.gov, info@begich.com info@jeffsessions.com intern_coordinator@johnson.senate.gov, internapp@feinstein.senate.gov, internships@brownback.senate.gov, isaac_edwards@murkowski.senate.gov, jack@reed.senate.gov, jackie_cottrell@roberts.senate.gov, jackie_erickson@casey.senate.gov, jackie_parker@levin.senate.gov, jacqueline_lampert@johnson.senate.gov, jacqueline_wood@demint.senate.gov, James_brown@casey.senate.gov, james_chang@inouye.senate.gov, james_wallner@sessions.senate.gov, james_wallner@sessions.senate.gov, jan_fowler@voinovich.senate.gov, Jane_Campbell@landrieu.senate.gov, Janice_Miller@reid.senate.gov, jason_matthews@landrieu.senate.gov, Jason_mulvihill@ensign.senate.gov, jason_vanbeek@thune.senate.gov, Jeff_Connaughton@kaufman.senate.gov, jeff_gohringer@johnson.senate.gov, jen_olson@lgraham.senate.gov, Jennifer_Barrett@markudall.senate.gov, jennifer_cook@roberts.senate.gov, Jennifer_Hensley@tester.senate.gov, Jennifer_Piorkowski@merkley.senate.gov, jennifer_romans@kyl.senate.gov, Jennifer_Sawaya@reid.senate.gov, Jennifer_swenson@roberts.senate.gov, Jesse_BroderVanDyke@akaka.senate.gov, Jesse_Walls@Voinovich.senate.gov, Jessica_Bantham@reid.senate.gov, Jessica_Satre@reid.senate.gov, jim_askins@bunning.senate.gov, jim_bunning@bunning.senate.gov, jim_fenton@dodd.senate.gov, jim_inhofe@inhofe.senate.gov, Jim_Manley@reid.senate.gov, Jim_Manley@reid.senate.gov, jim_molinari@feinstein.senate.gov, Jim_Reilly@carper.senate.gov, jim_stowers@lincoln.senate.gov, jim_turner@levin.senate.gov, joan_kirchner@isakson.senate.gov, joann_papenfuss@stabenow.senate.gov, joaquin_esquivel@boxer.senate.gov, Joe_Campbell@Klobuchar.senate.gov, joe_donoghue@mccain.senate.gov, Joe_Shoemaker@Durbin.Senate.gov, joel_shapiro@wyden.senate.gov, jofi_joseph@casey.senate.gov, john_lewis@baucus.senate.gov, john_lopez@ensign.senate.gov, john_rankin@brownback.senate.gov, John_Richter@snowe.senate.gov, John_Stilliana@Voinovich.senate.gov, john_watts@feinstein.senate.gov, Jon_Selib@baucus.senate.gov, jon_selib@baucus.senate.gov, jon_yoshimura@akaka.senate.gov, jonathan_becker@klobuchar.senate.gov, jonathan_coppess@bennelson.senate.gov, jonathan_graffeo@shelby.senate.gov, jordanna_levinson@whitehouse.senate.gov, josh_kardon@wyden.senate.gov, josh_sargen@bayh.senate.gov, joshua_blumenfeld@dodd.senate.gov, joshua_sheinkman@wyden.senate.gov, Joy_Mulinex@levin.senate.gov, judy_vrchota@thune.senate.gov, Julianne_Fisher@johnson.senate.gov, julie_adams@mcconnell.senate.gov, Julie_Blackorby@demint.senate.gov, Julie_Wirkkala@kerry.senate.gov, jurani@ensign.senate.gov, justin_clay@chambliss.senate.gov, justin_clay@chambliss.senate.gov, kara_stein@reed.senate.gov, kara_stein@reed.senate.gov, Karen_Silberstein@reid.senate.gov, kasey_gillette@casey.senate.gov, kassandra_cerveny@billnelson.senate.gov, kata_sybenga@levin.senate.gov, Kate_Howard@bennelson.senate.gov, Kate_Nicolai@landrieu.senate.gov, kate_nilan@klobuchar.senate.gov, kate_nilan@klobuchar.senate.gov, Katherine_Oh@reid.senate.gov, Kathleen_Amacio@johanns.senate.gov, Kathleen_Rozner@reid.senate.gov, Kathy_nuebel@grassley.senate.gov, katie_downs@crapo.senate.gov, katie_laning@lincoln.senate.gov, katie_platt@billnelson.senate.gov, katie_platt@billnelson.senate.gov, ken_lundberg@martinez.senate.gov, kendra_barkoff@casey.senate.gov, kenneth_martin@johnson.senate.gov, kevin_bishop@lgraham.senate.gov, Kevin_glandon@levin.senate.gov, Khisha_Fallon@Voinovich.senate.gov, kim_dean@bunning.senate.gov, kimberly_gluck@demint.senate.gov, kolan_davis@grassley.senate.gov, Kris_Sarri@commerce.senate.gov, krista_lamoreaux@johnson.senate.gov, kristen_daimler@murkowski.senate.gov, kristen_daimler-nothdurft@murkowski.senate.gov, kristin_wikelius@feinstein.senate.gov, kristina_ko@levin.senate.gov, kurt_kovarik@grassley.senate.gov, kyle_downey@thune.senate.gov, landon_fulmer@brownback.senate.gov, Laura_Bauld@lGraham.senate.gov, laura_friedel@shelby.senate.gov, Laura_Ochoa@reid.senate.gov, laura_schiller@boxer.senate.gov, laura_swanson@johnson.senate.gov, Lauren_Edwards@lgraham.senate.gov, Lauri_Hettinger@Voinovich.senate.gov, laverne_saulny@landrieu.senate.gov, leann_crosby@mcconnell.senate.gov, lee_dunn@mccain.senate.gov, Lee_Sheehy@Klobuchar.senate.gov, leslie_ridle@transition.senate.gov, Linda_Greenwood@Voinovich.senate.gov, lindsay_calderone@klobuchar.senate.gov, Lindsay_mabry@chambliss.senate.gov, lisa@lisamurkowski.com Lisa_Zellers@Voinovich.senate.gov, liz_king@reed.senate.gov, Lois_Santiago@dodd.senate.gov, lucy_murfitt@kyl.senate.gov, Lucy_Stickan@Voinovich.senate.gov, madeline_otto@billnelson.senate.gov, Maggie_ward@Roberts.senate.gov, Margaret_ballard@crapo.senate.gov, Maria_Plakoudas@specter.senate.gov, marie_blanco@inouye.senate.gov, Marie_Francis@Bayh.senate.gov, Mariela_Hernandez@reid.senate.gov, Marjorie_duske@klobuchar.senate.gov, mark_haugen@thune.senate.gov, mark_hayes@lugar.senate.gov, mark_powden@brown.senate.gov, mark_pryor@pryor.senate.gov, mark_pryor@pryor.senate.gov, mark_salter@mccain.senate.gov, Mark_Shonce@Risch.senate.gov, mark_Wetjen@reid.senate.gov, marques_chavez@crapo.senate.gov, martha_pabon@bayh.senate.gov, Mary_Conelly@reid.senate.gov, mary_gautreaux@wyden.senate.gov, mary_yoshioka@inouye.senate.gov, MaryJane_Collipriest@bennett.senate.gov, matt_hoskins@demint.senate.gov, matt_hoskins@demint.senate.gov, Matt_Jennings@tester.senate.gov, matt_koranda@levin.senate.gov, matt_mckenna@tester.senate.gov, Matt_Rimkunas@lGraham.senate.gov, matt_thornblad@johnson.senate.gov, matthew_pippin@akaka.senate.gov, Matthew_Tuma@reid.senate.gov, max@baucus.senate.gov, meghan_keck@bayh.senate.gov, mel_martinez@martinez.senate.gov, melanie_benning@brownback.senate.gov, melanie_rogge@bennelson.senate.gov, Melanie_Rogge@bennelson.senate.gov, meredith_brown@thune.senate.gov, michael_bassett@martinez.senate.gov, Michael_Dustman@Voinovich.senate.gov, michael_quiello@isakson.senate.gov, michael_teague@pryor.senate.gov, Michael_Vannozzi@reid.senate.gov, michael_weiss@boxer.senate.gov, Michael_Zamore@merkley.senate.gov, michael_zehr@martinez.senate.gov, Michelle_Shwimer@casey.senate.gov, Michelle_spence@ensign.senate.gov, Mike_Esposito@reid.senate.gov, mike_kuiken@levin.senate.gov, mike_reynard@bunning.senate.gov, Mike_Schwartz@Coburn.senate.gov, mike_seyfert@roberts.senate.gov, mike_steenhoek@grassley.senate.gov, miles_Lackey@dodd.senate.gov, Mindy_Myers@whitehouse.senate.gov, molly_brenner@markudall.senate.gov, molly_manning@isakson.senate.gov, molly_mueller@roberts.senate.gov, Moon_Sulfab@mcconnell.senate.gov, morna_murray@casey.senate.gov, Natalie_cook@bennett.senate.gov, natalie_ravitz@boxer.senate.gov, Natasha_Guynes@reid.senate.gov, nathan_graham@bennett.senate.gov, Nathan_Steinwald@casey.senate.gov, Neal_Orringer@Dodd.Senate.gov, Neil_Campbell@reed.senate.gov, Neil_Kornze@reid.senate.gov, nick_matiella@mccain.senate.gov, Nick_Watts@kennedy.senate.gov, nicole_morse@dodd.senate.gov, Nicole_tapay@wyden.senate.gov, Nicole_Trzynadlowski@reid.senate.gov, noushin_jahanian@stabenow.senate.gov, Oliver_Kim@stabenow.senate.gov, olyvia_rodriguez@feinstein.senate.gov, open_positions@casey.senate.gov, pat_roberts@roberts.senate.gov, Pat_Souders@Durbin.senate.gov, patricia_readinger@stabenow.senate.gov, paul_wilkins@baucus.senate.gov, peter_cleveland@feinstein.senate.gov, Phil_Park@Voinovich.senate.gov, press@whitehouse.senate.gov, pressjobs@stabenow.senate.gov, qusi_alhaj@thune.senate.gov, Racquel_Russell@Carper.senate.gov, Reb_Brownell@mcconnell.senate.gov, regan_fitzgerald@whitehouse.senate.gov, regina_campbell@specter.senate.gov, requests@begich.senate.gov, Richard_Bender@harkin.senate.gov, richard_fontaine@mccain.senate.gov, richard_harper@feinstein.senate.gov, Richard_Perry@lgraham.senate.gov, richard_spiegelman@casey.senate.gov, Richelle_Zakrzewski@Voinovich.senate.gov, rick_dearborn@sessions.senate.gov, Robert_Herbert@reid.senate.gov, Robert_Sharp@reid.senate.gov, robert_steurer@mcconnell.senate.gov, Robin_McCain@reid.senate.gov, roger_fisher@lincoln.senate.gov, rohini_ravindran@stabenow.senate.gov, roland_burris@burris.senate.gov, Rosanne_Haroian@reed.senate.gov, rosanne_haroian@reed.senate.gov, Roy_Hansen@crapo.senate.gov, rsvp_whitehouse@whitehouse.senate.gov, ryan_jackson@inhofe.senate.gov, ryan_patmintra@kyl.senate.gov, ryan_thompson@inhofe.senate.gov, sallie_derr@wyden.senate.gov, sara_kuban@baucus.senate.gov, Sara_Kuban@baucus.senate.gov, sara_mabry@casey.senate.gov, sarada_peri@landrieu.senate.gov, sarah_little@roberts.senate.gov, Sarah_Nixon@whitehouse.senate.gov, sarah_rozensky@bayh.senate.gov, sarah_timoney@bunning.senate.gov, saxby_chambliss@chambliss.senate.gov, scheduler_landrieu@landrieu.senate.gov, scott_gerber@feinstein.senate.gov, Scott_Hoeflich@specter.senate.gov, scott_raab@mcconnell.senate.gov, sean_moore@boxer.senate.gov, seema_singh@specter.senate.gov, senator.klobuchar@senate.gov, senator@akaka.senate.gov, senator@bayh.senate.gov, senator@bayh.senate.gov, senator@begich.senate.gov, senator@bennelson.senate.gov, senator@bennett.senate.gov, senator@boxer.senate.gov, senator@demint.senate.gov, senator@levin.senate.gov, senator@merkley.senate.gov, senator@pryor.senate.gov, senator@shelby.senate.gov, senator@stabenow.senate.gov, senator@tester.senate.gov, senator_DeMint@DeMint.senate.gov, Senator_Inouye@inouye.senate.gov, senator_lugar@lugar.senate.gov, Senator_Mark_Udall@markudall.senate.gov, senator_rolandburris@burris.senate.gov, Shannon_Raborn@reid.senate.gov, sheldon_whitehouse@whitehouse.senate.gov, sheri_davie@stabenow.senate.gov, sherry_kuntz@grassley.senate.gov, Siad_Ali@klobuchar.senate.gov, simone_hardeman@klobuchar.senate.gov, Sonja_Dean@johnson.senate.gov, spencer_wayne@martinez.senate.gov, staci_stevenson@crapo.senate.gov, Stephanie_allen@landrieu.senate.gov, stephanie_schriock@tester.senate.gov, Steve_Abbott@collins.senate.gov, Steve_Keenan@reed.senate.gov, steve_rebillot@chambliss.senate.gov, Steven_meeks@chambliss.senate.gov, Susan_Lisagor@reid.senate.gov, susan_wheeler@crapo.senate.gov, susie_quinn@billnelson.senate.gov, suzanne_meledeo@inhofe.senate.gov, talal_mir@mccain.senate.gov, tara_andringa@levin.senate.gov, tara_trujillo@markudall.senate.gov, tate_heuer@pryor.senate.gov, Teresa_Frank@Voinovich.senate.gov, terri_glaze@pryor.senate.gov, Terri_Moore@johanns.senate.gov, thomas_dower@specter.senate.gov, tim@johnson.senate.gov, Tim_Becker@bennelson.senate.gov, tim_glazewski@kyl.senate.gov, todd_stubbendieck@johnson.senate.gov, Tom_Faletti@durbin.senate.gov, tom_harkin@harkin.senate.gov, Tom_Kotarac@durbin.senate.gov, tom_sugar@bayh.senate.gov, tom_sullivan@klobuchar.senate.gov, tomiko_gumbleton@stabenow.senate.gov, tory_mazzola@ensign.senate.gov, Trecia_McEvoy@tester.senate.gov, Tricia_Chastain@isakson.senate.gov, Tyler_Owens@bennett.senate.gov, tyler_thompson@isakson.senate.gov, van_luong@inouye.senate.gov, vance_serchuk@lieberman.senate.gov, Verna_Regier@roberts.senate.gov, Victor_Mercado@reid.senate.gov, Walt_Kuhn@LGraham.senate.gov, wayne_kinney@wyden.senate.gov, webmaster@boxer.senate.gov, wendi_price@inhofe.senate.gov, wes_hickman@lgraham.senate.gov, Wesley_denton@demint.senate.gov, Will_Sehestedt@baucus.senate.gov, Yolanda_Garcia-Banuelos@reid.senate.gov, yuna_jacobson@lautenberg.senate.gov,

As Obama acts, Atlas shrugs weary shoulders

For almost nine months during the 2008 campaign I wrote about the dangers of Barack Obama's socialist views and liberal voting record -- both in the Illinois State Senate and United States Senate. I argued that his goal of "spreading the wealth" around would amount to a new socialist era in America, with tax and spend policies that were designed to transfer wealth from a shrinking percentage of tax payers to a growing percentage Americans "on the dole". Critics of my views kept telling me that I was wrong -- that Obama is a "new style" politician -- one who understands the importance of compromise and who would govern as a pragmatist from "the center". I was highly skeptical. Nothing in Obama's record led me to believe that he was anything other than a classic "tax and spend" liberal interested in using government for social engineering purposes. "Prove me wrong" I said on many occasions to images of Obama on the television (I said many other things to him as well, but this is a family blog).

Sadly, Obama has instead proven me right. Though he has mastered the image of bipartisanship -- inviting conservative Rick Warren to give the invocation at the inauguration, having Republicans to the White House for tea and cookies -- his actions have shown him to be true to his liberal roots. The so-called "stimulus package" now before the U.S. Senate has become an increasingly unpopular pork-laden spending bill served up by Nancy Pelosi and her cohorts, designed to enact social change rather than economic growth. Rather than choosing a truly bipartisan process for creating the bill -- to include targeted infrastructure spending and tax cuts to stimulate job creation -- Obama chose to throw a bone to every left-wing social and environmental cause, using tax payer money to "stimulate" social policy objectives. As opposition from Republicans grew, Obama chose to attack rather than compromise, lashing out at Republicans for their "tired old ways" of arguing that "government is the problem and that tax cuts are always the answer". To Obama, of course, government is the answer and tax cuts are for the rich -- exactly what you'd expect to hear from a socialist.

It is amazing to me that Obama calls this a job creation bill, for the only jobs this will create are in the public sector. Doling out cash to people to spend is not the same thing as creating an environment where employers will start to hire again. Businesses require structural relief -- tax relief -- to create the economic incentives necessary to spur new jobs. But Obama doesn't see the private sector as the real engine of growth -- he pointedly sees government in that role. For Obama, an economic stimulus that leads to New Deal-style public works programs is the ticket to getting out of this recession. Never mind that the original New Deal in the 1930s only served to prolong the Great Depression. In the minds of big-government liberals, FDR is a hero, and the conventional orthodoxy that government can solve the people's problems is alive and well.

It is hard to stomach what is going on now in Washington -- from the continued wasting of taxpayer's hard earned money to the hypocrisy of Obama's cabinet nominees who don't mind raising people's taxes because they apparently don't pay their own. Now we have the specter of the Federal government telling companies how much they can compensate their top executives because they took public funds -- funds that in certain cases the government forced them to take against their will. It's all so reminiscent of Atlas Shrugged: collectivist action denying the ability for those who create wealth to do so, and then confiscating their gains in the name of societal "good". This cannot -- and will not -- end well.

As I've said many times, elections have consequences. We shall see if a newly resurgent Republicans can use concrete proof of Obama's socialist plans to regain some momentum. 

No jihadists to Supermax, continued

Seems I hit a nerve with my post about Gov. Ritter's collision with international law if Gitmo prisoners are moved to Colorado SuperMax. Indignant comments by Bill Menezes on this site and at PoliticsWest.com claimed I'm all wet. But his objections shatter on the clear text of the Geneva Conventions and relevant case law. His attempt to obfuscate salient facts with irrelevant minutiae fails the test of common sense, as well as established national and international legal precedent.

As mentioned in my original post, the salient fact is the prohibition on internment of combatant detainees (both actual prisoners of war and “unlawful combatants” – more on that later) in civilian penitentiaries.

In the operative provision, Menezes puts undue weight on the qualifying language before the comma: "Except in particular cases which are justified by the interest of the prisoners themselves, they shall not be interned in penitentiaries."

Common sense will inform the reader that the “particular cases” exception to the general rule is applied to individual detainees who are, for whatever reason (generally certain medical conditions, threats from fellow prisoners, or conviction of a civil crime in addition to their combatant detention status) better served or cared for in a civilian facility. Note that this exception is expressly in the interest of the prisoners themselves, not for the convenience or political benefit of the detaining power.

However, since common sense appears to be in general short supply, there is also an established body of case law and the commentary of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) that applies:

“Internment of prisoners of war in [p.183] penitentiaries is in principle prohibited because of the painful psychological impressions which such places might create for prisoners of war.” Citation here.

So in summary: The facts of international law and treaty (Geneva Convention III Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War) and our obligations under those laws (and U.S. statute) are clear: persons falling under military jurisdiction as prisoners (irrespective of their combatant status) are NOT to be detained in civilian penitentiaries as a matter of policy.

Some exceptions MAY be made on a case-by-case basis, in the interest of the prisoners themselves, but in practice and precedent this is applied VERY restrictively. Ergo, Governor Ritter’s proposal to bring detainees from Guantanamo en masse to Colorado’s civilian SuperMax prison would in fact violate international law and our treaty obligations.

PS - The non-functioning link correctly pointed out by Bill in the original post has now been corrected. We apologize for the typo. The link goes to the Yale University Law Library’s “Avalon Project” – a superb resource and reference for documents on international law.