Calling socialists by their right name

They used to call themselves Liberals, until “liberal” took on negative connotations. Now they prefer to be called Progressives, but in truth they should be called what they really are…Socialists. The term “Liberal” is derived from the word “Liberty”, which should describe someone who seeks greater freedom: economic freedom, intellectual freedom, etc. How could those who want to limit our economic freedom through greater government regulation be called liberal? How could those who monopolize academia and purge those few remaining professors who question their prevailing “orthodoxy” be called liberal?

Over the past few decades the word “Liberal” has often been used in derision, so those on the left have preferred the term “Progressive”. But “Progressive” is derived from the word “Progress”, which should describe those who actually bring progress: greater efficiency, increased opportunity, higher standards of living, etc. Have the policies pushed by the left actually brought progress?

Do labor unions bring greater progress? Back in the 70s, when I first visited London, the city was virtually shut down. A general strike had been called by the labor unions in sympathy with the typesetters of the London print industry, whose jobs were threatened by new computer technology. The unions wanted to continue the centuries-old practice of setting each letter of type by hand. Had the unions gotten their way and held back technological progress, they would have destroyed the English print industry.

Does socialism bring greater liberty? Back in the 70s, while stationed with the army in West Berlin, I regularly visited the Wall, designed to keep those who wanted liberty trapped in their oppressive system. Fifteen years later, before the fall of that Wall, I was able to visit East Berlin as a teacher leading a group of students. The communist tour guide told us that they had no unemployment in their supposed “worker’s paradise.” I whispered to my students, that workers were not free to quit their jobs and to not work was to be forced into a labor camp. Our guide also informed us that there were no homeless on their streets like there were in America. I whispered again, that if there were any homeless they would be scooped up against their will and deposited in mental institutions.

Does government interference in Free Markets bring progress? Back in the 80s when I first visited the Soviet Union, I was amazed how the greater part of the population lived in poverty. I visited the apartments of common Russians living in squalor in the large government apartment blocks, but never saw the pleasant dachas of party officials. I wandered through the shops with empty shelves and saw the long lines in front of those shops when they actually had something worth buying. I noticed two kinds of cars: the shabby little Lada with a lawnmower engine driven by those lucky enough to get one after years on a waiting list. I also saw the sleek, chauffer-driven sedans of the party officials. There were even lanes in the middle of the road reserved for those party officials. The socialist experiment which promised Russians equality and progress was an abject failure.

What kind of world awaits us, if we trust our future to those pseudo-liberal, pseudo-progressives? Will they really bring us the liberty, equality, and progress they promise, or will it be the maximum security, inequality, inefficiency and backwardness of what I saw in the 70s and 80s?

Teacher's Desk: Conracks of Colo.

Maybe I need to eat my words, or at least nibble them, when the Denver Post now informs us the DPS board and superintendent support new charter school proposals, as well as, innovative schools. Although I am a strong supporter of innovation, the funny thing with innovation schools is that the district still pays for their facilities; charter schools pay for their own facilities. Innovation schools continue to pay teachers at the current pay schedule. Since charter schools pay for their own facilities, they usually cannot afford the same pay as district schools for their educators. Personally, I’m willing to take a $10,000 a year “cut” (it’s not really a cut unless I received it) by working at a school that treats me with respect and allows me to give input to improve student success. I deal with a reasonable administration and board and not a layer of bureaucracy in between. I like that. I have been checking out a lot of other education blogs lately and will continue to do so as I discover them. Ed is Watching is an Independent Institute blog informing readers of federal and state legislation involving education. Jay P. Greene’s blog is truly eclectic on many education issues. Dr. Greene is the chairman of the Department of Education Reform at the University of Arkansas and President of the Manhattan Institute. David Saba and colleagues write for ABCTE. This blog informs on alternative teacher licensure. David has an on-line program for those who choose teaching as a career after receiving a baccalaureate degree without education classes. Many times it is a mid-life change for professionals in many different fields. I ran on a platform supporting alternative licensure as a candidate for the State Board of Education back in 1990 when Colorado did not have any alternatives to teacher licensure. I took advantage of alternative licensure much later on when Colorado allowed for alternative licensure. I am a graduate of such a program. I truly support this on-line program as it could bring opportunities for teaching careers in rural Colorado and provides the opportunity to develop really great teachers!!

As I finish coding the backs of CSAP booklets (a truly tedious chore), I am looking forward to my annual trip to Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. My husband plays golf with his sister and we dine on awesome seafood---especially oysters! Last year, I took a tour to Daufuskie Island, a twenty-minute ferry ride away. Daufuskie is the island portrayed by author, Pat Conroy’s (Prince of Tides) book, The Water is Wide. There was a movie back in the 1980s about this story, I believe, starring Jon Voight called “Conrack.” It told the story of a 1960s idealist, Conroy, teaching isolated “Gullah” students about the world, society, life skills, and academics including music. The young teachers I work with are all “Conracks!” They don’t know that there is a “NO.” They only see “what if?” I like that.

I am lucky that many of us, including myself, value education. Accidentally, I instilled that in my youngest son. My 22-year-old son graduating from the University of Colorado in Colorado Springs this May with a B. S. in Engineering has been accepted to Virginia Tech’s graduate program in doctoral studies. That is very, very uncommon to go straight into a doctoral program and he is slated to be a teaching assistant.

I hope they give him a classroom. As a 14-year-old, he was an amazing math tutor. I would really like to start a program that has the Brendans of the country go into the middle schools and speak to students about loving mathematics and what mathematics and science can do for them.

What do you think? Is this something we can develop across the country? Let me know. Kathleen Kullback is a licensed special educator at an alternative high school charter with an M.A. in educational leadership and is a former candidate to the State Board of Education.

Obama the wanderer

I've been struggling over the last few weeks to put my finger on what bothers me so much about Barack Obama. Yes, I know that sounds strange coming from me -- since the pages of my blog are filled with criticisms of the man and his beliefs. But there is something else that is bugging me about the Obama presidency, and it isn't so much about policy as it is a feeling that I have -- a sense of the peripatetic way he is going about this very serious job he has. I've been watching Obama now travel from media event to media event, fluttering about the country with much fanfare but little substance. There is something missing. A sense of steadiness. His devotion to his teleprompter -- already the stuff of scorn and ridicule -- is unsettling. Wasn't he supposed to be the eloquent one who wields a brilliant intellect? The next great communicator?

Peggy Noonan does a masterful job in today's Wall Street Journal of putting my sense of Obama into words -- it's a must read. I've been frustrated with Noonan's commentary about Obama since the election -- she seemed all too willing to accept the notion that Obama really is some new, transcendental leader. But no more. This most recent piece captures perfectly the true essence of the "Obama phenomena" -- full of sound and fury, and signifying nothing:

He is willowy when people yearn for solid, reed-like where they hope for substantial, a bright older brother when they want Papa, cool where they probably prefer warmth. All of which may or may not hurt Barack Obama in time...

Such impressions—coolness, slightness—can come to matter only if they capture or express some larger or more meaningful truth. At the moment they connect, for me, to something insubstantial and weightless in the administration's economic pronouncements and policies. The president seems everywhere and nowhere, not fully focused on the matters at hand. He's trying to keep up with the news cycle with less and less to say.

Our new president is chasing the news cycle, going on Jay Leno and following the cues from the dwarfs in Congress -- that august body of tax cheats and pork spenders where Obama most recently worked. He is engaged in a dance of reaction as opposed to a steady march of action, all at a time when we are dealing with crisis at home and war abroad. This is a time for steeliness and strength, and what we have is unfocused, peripatetic waffling.

Those of you who read this blog know that this comes as no surprise to me. Barack Obama is a man of great salesmanship, who understands how to get you excited to buy something, but then knows nothing of the details once you've purchased it. He's already on to the next sale, the next opportunity to close the deal and show his ability to convince and cajole. His sense of office is a constant campaign -- lots of platitudes and generalities, the kind of stuff that makes crowds clap. He's a jack of all and master of none. And now that he is the master of our collective domain -- the United States of America -- the weaknesses show through with growing clarity and alarm.

As Noonan succinctly argues, Obama has two jobs -- to fix the economy and to keep us safe. On both scores he seems wanting. When Dick Cheney recently criticized Obama for making us less safe in the wake of his recent decisions on Guantanamo and interrogation, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs reacted with disdain. Mr. Cheney is part of a 'Republican cabal.' 'I guess Rush Limbaugh was busy.' This was cheap."

Cheap and wrong. For whatever you wish to say about Dick Cheney, he know of what he speaks -- having seen first hand the post 9/11 intelligence briefings for 8 years. Cheney knows that the threat from Islamic terrorism is a constant drumbeat that can't be wished or talked away. He knows that the Obama administration has not yet found a serious footing on this issue -- and that this puts the country at risk. Noonan says it well:

What can be used will be used. We are a target. Something bad is going to happen—don't we all know this? Are we having another failure of imagination?

A month ago former FBI director Robert Mueller, in a speech to the Council on Foreign Relations, warned of Mumbai-type terrorist activity, saying a similar attack could happen in a U.S. city. He spoke of the threat of homegrown terrorists who are "radicalized," "indoctrinated" and recruited for jihad. Mumbai should "reinvigorate" U.S. intelligence efforts. The threat is not only from al Qaeda but "less well known groups." This had the hard sound of truth.

Contrast it with the new secretary of homeland security, Janet Napolitano, who, in her first speech and testimony to congress, the same week as Mr. Mueller's remarks, did not mention the word terrorism once. This week in an interview with Der Spiegel, she was pressed: "Does Islamist terrorism suddenly no longer pose a threat to your country?" Her reply: "I presume there is always a threat from terrorism." It's true she didn't use the word terrorism in her speech, but she did refer to "man-caused" disasters. "This is perhaps only a nuance, but it demonstrates that we want to move away from the politics of fear."

Ah. Well this is only a nuance, but her use of language is a man-caused disaster.

Exactly right. Eight years after 9/11 and two wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and we are still learning the same lesson over and over again: there are enemies who want to destroy us out there, they are Islamic fundamentalists and they can and will use any weapon they can get their hands on -- from machine guns to suitcase nuclear bombs. It isn't an issue of nuance, it is one of survival. The administration's responses -- as Dick Cheney points out -- should in no way be comforting.

These are the two great issues, the economic crisis and our safety. In the face of them, what strikes one is the weightlessness of the Obama administration, the jumping from issue to issue and venue to venue from day to day. Isaiah Berlin famously suggested a leader is a fox or a hedgehog. The fox knows many things but the hedgehog knows one big thing. In political leadership the hedgehog has certain significant advantages, focus and clarity of vision among them. Most presidents are one or the other. So far Mr. Obama seems neither.

Very well said, Peggy.

Some hard truths

Fellow conservative blogger Donald Douglas has an interesting post up that cites Robert Bork's recent book entitled: A Time To Speak:Selected Writings and Arguments. Many of you will remember Bork as having been an unfair victim of left-wing demagoguery during his 1987 Senate confirmation hearings after Ronald Reagan nominated him for the U.S. Supreme Court. Though beaten in that instance, Bork has been unbowed in using his prodigious intellectual talents to influence the national debate via his writings over the past 20 years. As Douglas recounts, Bork wrote back in 1995 with uncanny prescience in his essay Hard Truths About the Culture War that we face a real and growing threat from liberalism that is destroying our culture: Modern liberalism is most particularly a disease of our cultural elites, the people who control the institutions that manufacture or disseminate ideas, attitudes, and symbols-universities, some churches, Hollywood, the national press (print and electronic), much of the congressional Democratic party and some of the congressional Republicans as well, large sections of the judiciary, foundation staffs, and almost all the "public interest" organizations that exercise a profound if largely unseen effect on public policy. So pervasive is the influence of those who occupy the commanding heights of our culture that it is not entirely accurate to call the United States a majoritarian democracy. The elites of modern liberalism do not win all the battles, but despite their relatively small numbers, they win more than their share and move the culture always in one direction ....

What we are seeing in modern liberalism is the ultimate triumph of the New Left of the 1960s - the New Left that collapsed as a unified political movement and splintered into a multitude of intense, single-issue groups. We now have, to name but a few, radical feminists, black extremists, animal rights groups, radical environmentalists, activist homosexual groups, multiculturalists, People for the American Way, Planned Parenthood, the American Civil Liberties Union, and many more. In a real sense, however, the New Left did not collapse. Each of its splinters pursues a leftist agenda, but there is no publicly announced overarching philosophy that enables people to see easily that the separate groups and causes add up to a general radical left philosophy. The groups support one another and come together easily on many issues. In that sense, the splintering of the New Left made it less visible and therefore more powerful, its goals more attainable, than ever before.

In their final stages, radical egalitarianism becomes tyranny and radical individualism descends into hedonism. These translate as bread and circuses. Government grows larger and more intrusive in order to direct the distribution of goods and services in an ever more equal fashion, while people are diverted, led to believe that their freedoms are increasing, by a great variety of entertainments featuring violence and sex ...

As Douglas also notes, the "splintered" left-wing groups that Bork described in 1995 look a lot like the various liberal organizations that have now organized to make change within the Obama Administration.

An excellent example of this can be found in Ben Smith's recent article at Politico.com entitled: Unity '09 -- Dem Groups Quietly Align:

A broad coalition of left-leaning groups is quietly closing ranks into a new coalition, "Unity '09," aimed at helping President Barack Obama push his agenda through Congress.

Conceived at a New York meeting before the November election, two Democrats familiar with the planning said, Unity '09 will draw together money and grassroots organizations to pressure lawmakers in their home states to back White House legislation and other progressive causes.

The online-based MoveOn.org is a central player in the nascent organization, but other groups involved in planning Unity '09 span a broad spectrum of interests, from the American Civil Liberties Union to the National Council of La Raza to Planned Parenthood, as well as labor unions and environmental groups.

The obvious point to be made here is that the most radical of left-wing interest groups are organizing to have a major impact on public policy in the Obama White House. What follows logically from this is a pro-choice, pro-illegal immigration, pro-tort/pro-defendant and pro-union orientation that will systematically weaken the foundation of our nation and our economy. Just today, for example, it was revealed that estimates for Obama's "Cap and Trade" environmental protection regime will cost the economy well over $1 trillion over the next several years -- a huge tax on business in the name of satisfying the global warming alarmists who seek curbs on carbon at any cost.

With the Obama presidency we have opened the West Wing to the worst kind of single-minded interest groups -- for whom the word "compromise" and "in the national interest" have absolutely no meaning. There is no quid-pro-quo among the true believers, who have organized their lives around unyielding belief in the importance of a single issue -- be it abortion, immigration, torture, civil liberties or the environment.  For these disciples, there is no second place  -- total victory is the only option.  And for those of us who believe in open, honest debate, this is a hard truth, indeed.

Emotion vs. logic on tuitions

Susan Barnes-Gelt, "inspired by the intelligence, work ethic and generosity of spirit of the Mexican people" after a recent vacation down there, says Colorado should provide in-state tuition for illegal aliens. Firing back in the March round of Head On TV debates, John Andrews says that idea flunks, it's "flat wrong." John on the right, Susan on the left, also go at it this month over Wall Street bonuses, the union card check proposal, road and transit funding, and Obama's mandate - if any. Head On has been a daily feature on Colorado Public Television since 1997. Here are all five scripts for March: 1. IN-STATE TUITION FOR ILLEGAL ALIENS

John: Something like 20 million individuals from Mexico and other countries are illegally present in the United States. Public policy should discourage them from staying here, not encourage them, especially at a time of rising unemployment and declining tax revenues. The proposal giving illegal aliens in-state college tuition is flat wrong.

Susan: Just back from 2 weeks in the Yucatan, I am again inspired by the intelligence, work ethic and generosity of spirit of the Mexican people. Ensuring the children of undocumented immigrants who depart their wonderful country to find work, are educated - is in America's best interest.

John: Stop the cameras, I’m getting verklempt. Seriously, Susan, our family has enjoyed Mexico’s hospitality as well, though today with the drug cartels I’m not so sure. But that has nothing to do with cheap college for immigration lawbreakers. On the rule of law and fiscal responsibility, that idea flunks.

Susan: These kids aren't criminals anymore than the offspring of a Klanner is a racist. There will be no fiscal impact to the budget, students must seek citizenship and the bill comports with proposed federal legislation. An educated workforce is good for Colorado. Republican opposition is - at best - myopic.

2. COLORADO TRANSPORTATION TANGLE

John: Everyone agrees Colorado needs safer roads and bridges, increased highway capacity, and better public transit. But the Democrats don’t have a clue about how to get us there. First they increased the car tax 250 million. Now they want to decrease existing funds 300 million. Colorado drivers end up worse off.

Susan: Colorado drivers are hampered by decades of inadequate investment in roads, bridges and transit. Thanks to a state budget crippled by TABOR, we lacked shovel ready projects and Colorado was 49th in dollars from the federal stimulus. That and RTD's utter incompetence put us way behind.

John: Forty-ninth in stimulus wasn’t TABOR’s fault. Ritter and Colorado’s DC Democrats pulled off that gem. Meanwhile in the state, as I said, Dems want to take away with one hand more road dollars than they gave with the other. And they want to double the RTD tax. How absurd.

Susan: RTD got legislative support to go to the ballot, prior to building consensus among the metro mayors. And until the agency makes key management changes and civic and political leaders get it together, the voters won't bite, This train's been hijacked by a ship of fools.

3. MICHAEL BENNET'S FIRST TEST

Susan: Senator Michael Bennet must navigate between Scylla and Charybdis. Bennet must chose between business and labor when he casts his vote on the Employees Free Choice Act, easing unionization of businesses by eliminating secret-ballots, allowing workers to sign a form prior to voting.

John: Free choice is the last thing this bill provides. It would force unwilling workers into unions, and drive up costs through arbitration. Harmful to prosperity and liberty. But Democrats love it as a pipeline for campaign funds. Is Bennet a party hack or his own man? This vote will tell.

Susan: If the issue were that clear - Bennet wouldn't be on the hook. Heavy handedness by big labor is matched by intimidation and bullying of big business. It's tough to organize a workplace where conditions, pay and benefits are fair. Both sides need a new model.

John: Come on. Labor bosses have had the advantage over employers under federal law for 70 years. Even with that advantage, fewer and fewer workers are choosing unions. Hence labor’s desperation for the easily manipulated card check instead of secret ballots. Card check will prolong the recession. Bennet should vote no.

4. AIG BONUSES & WALL STREET WOES

Susan: The Ain't I Greedy boys - aka AIG - are paying out $165 million in bonuses - nearly matching their $173 million federal bailout. The administration lacks legal authority to retract these payouts. Is nationalization of banks & financial institutions a better answer?

John: “Too big to fail” was never a good idea. Not last fall under Bush, not this spring under Obama. Nationalization of the big boys, whether in finance, automaking, or any industry, is absolutely the wrong way to go. Government should sell its shares, quit micromanaging, and let bankruptcy take its course.

Susan: I'm frustrated too by the behavior of the big boys - the banks, GM and Wall Street. However, if your house is built of wood and your neighbor, smoking in bed, set his on fire, you're going to call the fire department. Punishing the miscreant comes later.

John: It’s the American people who are getting punished by the economic incompetence of this president. AIG paid bonuses because the White House dropped the ball. The stock market erased trillions in wealth because investors have no confidence in Obama and his clueless advisors. This isn’t the change we were promised.

5. OBAMA'S FIRST TWO MONTHS

Susan: Obama inherited the worst economy since the 1930's and two wars. Despite the nattering nabobs of negativism - a majority of Americans continue to have confidence in his steady as we go demeanor. It took 8 years to get into this mess. It will take more than 90 days to get out.

John: Voters are giving Obama a honeymoon, but no greater than they gave other new presidents. Early mistakes have proved he’s all too human. Lobbyists, earmarks, a snub to Great Britain – the list goes on. Does he want to fix the financial crisis or just exploit it? Please, Mr. President: focus.

Susan: If Americans wanted 4 more years of the Bush agenda, McCain would be president and Congressional majorities wouldn't be so strong. The Dems won a mandate to change direction and implement their policies.

John: Voters gave Obama no mandate to body-slam the economy with a carbon tax. No mandate to roll back welfare reform. No mandate to give a billion dollars to Hamas with its agenda of exterminating Israel. No mandate to let Congress continue with earmarks. That’s not the change we were promised.