The defaming of the President, 2008

No one expects political campaigns to be as calm, rational and genteel as academic seminars (although even those aren’t what they used to be), and certainly not as illuminating as the Lincoln-Douglas debates of 1858, but the 2008 election was marked by defamation on as grand a scale as any in our nation’s history. George W. Bush may not be one of our great presidents, but he is not evil or insane. Yet the left wingers in our country, aided by a few right wingers, managed to craft an image of an administration that showed reckless disregard of the Constitution, the rights of both our citizens and foreigners, the requirements of diplomacy and our standing in the world.

Routinely, Bush was likened to Hitler, because he “invaded” Iraq, even though he was saving a people from tyranny, not imposing it. Government surveillance of enemy communications was misconstrued as “spying” on American citizens. Holding enemy combatants was confused with denying them due process rights. Indirect negotiations with Iran and six-party talks with North Korea were treated as nonexistent. These lies are only the tip of the iceberg.

This is defamation, which is “the utterance of a false statement that harms the reputation of another.” There is nothing wrong, of course, with uttering true statements that harm a person’s reputation (unless it is a privileged communication), but the distinction has been lost of late amidst the passion of self expression that has gripped our nation since the turbulent 1960s.

The turning point came with New York Times v. Sullivan (1965), a United States Supreme Court decision which held that even false statements are protected by the First Amendment if the writer or speaker did not know the statements were false at the time they were made. This constitutes malice. But, alas, the climate of allegedly “wide-open, robust debate” credits any statement agreeable to the passions of the media that publicize it.

Of course, it’s fair to say, as old pols have, that “politics ain’t beanbag,” and certainly Bush understands that, as he has been gracious under the verbal assaults and has filed no libel suits. He accepts Harry Truman’s admonition, viz., “If you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.”

It would incorrect to rank the recent campaign as the worst in history, for others come to mind, such as what the supporters of John Adams and Thomas Jefferson said about the opposing candidate in 1800, calling the former a tyrant and the latter a libertine. Or the campaign of Andrew Jackson’s supporters against incumbent John Quincy Adams in 1828, smearing that most virtuous of all presidents as immoral. Remember the nuclear blast commercial castigating Barry Goldwater in 1964?

What makes this year’s political defamation particularly galling is that it was uttered and disseminated by people in both party and media politics who make grandiose claims for their superior wisdom and virtue that are not warranted by the facts. No one has captured this pretentiousness better than Thomas Sowell, who has dubbed the advocates of the nanny state at home and appeasement abroad as “the anointed.”

Like the progressives of the late 19th and early 20th century, today’s incarnations see themselves as the better sort of people, whose job it is to lead the unenlightened masses to a promised land of harmony and plenty which is about as likely to arrive as the forever postponed utopia in the old Soviet Union. Neither the New Deal of Franklin Roosevelt nor the Great Society of Lyndon Johnson managed to raise the standard of living or bring people out of poverty. Only a free market has shown that it can do that.

Coming from what are purported to be the best colleges and universities in the country, liberal politicians and journalists believe they alone are “objective” in their analysis of the nation’s and the world’s ills. They speak a peculiar language characterized by moral neutrality regarding matters of morals and moral outrage about facts that displease them.

By the evidence of this last campaign, the anointed ones feel no compunction about uttering all manner of lies about those whose offices they covet, for their pie-in-the-sky ends justify any means. There is a far-left organization aptly named By Any Means Necessary (BAMN) that defames all those seeking to end racial preference in public policy.

Many Americans, including me, were disappointed that President Bush did not succeed in Iraq sooner than he did, or that he resorted to government bailouts to deal with an economic crisis. But they have elected a faction that will use our government to ensure defeat abroad and real economic depression at home. For that we can thank, at least in part, a campaign of defamation that reduces the complexity of political issues to a matter of the elite’s personal preferences.

'Ten Battles' surveys 2500 years

You've heard of the Battle of New Orleans, which ended the War of 1812. You may have heard of the Battle of Cowpens, a key engagement in America's war for independence. But you've likely not heard of the battles of Zama, Carrhae, Badr, Stamford Bridge, Sinop, and Khalkin Gol, nor of the Sack of Khwarezmia, nor of Israel's brilliant and epoch-making Operation Isotope in 1972.

They all deserve to be remembered today, however and all are discussed in a book I've just published; the press release follows:

Ten Battles is an exciting new book from Military Writers Press designed for the enjoyment and information of all those interested in history, the military, and important battles.

This is a striking exploration of history that can be enjoyed by both the academic and the general audience. Immediately and with enjoyable prose, author James J. Krefft takes his readers through the story of ten of history’s most important but least known battles. In a field replete with discussion of well known battles, Ten Battles examines seldom-discussed engagements that had lasting and important consequences of global significance. The book examines each of its case studies in detail and in context, discussing the prelude, actual engagement, aftermath and result with equal vigor. Readers are dazzled right off by the discussion of two Classical battles that were essential in Roman History.

The first of these is Zama, a keen engagement fought at the end of the 2nd Punic War that ended Carthage and catapulted Rome to Empire. Ten Battles then takes its readers to the desert of Iraq, where over 2000 years ago a battle was joined between horse and sword for the fate of Persia and perhaps the long term survival of the Roman Empire. Carrhae leaps off of the pages and engages the reader in one of histories most asymmetric battles, on that had lasting implications for Rome, Persia and the progress of Western Civilization in general. Next on the list of Ten Battles is Badr, an obscure and small scale affair that would have epic consequences for one of today's most prolific religions: Islam. At the time no more that a skirmish between desert tribes, Badr was still drastic as it set the context that Islam would use for expansion for the next 1000 years.

Next comes 1066, and an important battle fought in the wilds of England between Anglo-Saxon and Viking. Angry Vikings and angry Saxons clash at Stamford Bridge with nothing less then the future of the Vikings, England and even the Norman conquest at stake. The first half of the book is finished off with a discussion of the fame and infamy of Genghis Khan and his Mongol horseman. The Sack of Khwarezmia is a tragic tale, one of siege warfare, indirect theater based warfare and shameless slaughter. But Khwarezmia is also an important turning point in the course of Central Asia and the wider Mongol conquest.

Ten Battles starts you with 5 interesting and important battles but then gives you five more. In the second half of the book readers are taken through: Cowpens in the American Revolution, New Orleans in the War of 1812, then the Russians and Ottomans face off at Sinop, the Japanese and Soviets at Khalkhin Gol and finally the IDF and Terrorists during Operation Isotope in 1972. Ten Battles is a fast paced and entertaining book that informs readers on battles that might otherwise slip through the cracks. In elegant word in gives the reader a detailed and manageable course in the basics of battle, military campaign, and historical repercussion. Ten Battles answers fundamental questions about the progress of history by looking at root causes and the results of the formative events of some of histories most important trends. By understanding why things happened as they did we get a better idea of how to move forward with our future.

Excerpts from Ten Battles

** Just as an argument can be made for his brilliance, another can be made that Hannibal was another general whose spectacular tactical and strategic ability took him the length of the field, but not into the end zone. Unable to finish, he was betrayed far from home and died to join the likes of other spectacular but likewise unsuccessful commanders such as Rommel, Lee, Napoleon, and Attila.-Ten Battles, Zama

** A contingent of 40,000 Turks and slave soldiers had been supplemented by 60,000 irregular conscripts, and city fathers had amassed over three years of provisions in granaries and stores. Containers with water had been placed throughout the city, and the streets had been widened to inhibit the spread of fires. With all this said, it would take the Mongols only three days to take Samarkand.-Ten Battles, Khwarezmia

** Some Japanese units made it out of the Soviet encirclement, but when Komatsubara reached the safety of Japanese territory he had only four hundred survivors, meaning the 23rd Division had suffered over 90 percent casualties.-Ten Battles, Khalkhin-Gol

** In a world rife with Jihad, today’s governments would not have special-forces CT without this one small-scale battle fought in May 1972 at Lod Airport east of Tel Aviv, Israel. Operation Isotope pioneered the strategy, tactics, and toolkit of special-forces CT, and the engagement should be credited for what it accomplished and what it launched.-Ten Battles, Operation Isotope

2009: How strange will it be?

Satirizing politics isn't easy; your imaginary absurdity keeps getting overtaken by the real thing. It wasn't that long ago when we taped our twisted fantasy of 2009 for Colorado Public Television, but since then the Senate vacancy farce has exploded, and now there's the Broncos melodrama on top of that. Embarrassment of riches! Must have been too much merriment on 12/31, because I woke up on 1/1 thinking what a masterstroke it would be if Ritter named Mike Shanahan to Salazar's Senate seat. It could only help the Dem ticket in Colorado next year -- and what a way to take some of the media glare off Ritter's floundering fellow governors, Blago in IL and Patterson in NY, as they grasp for gravitas amid senatorial follies of their own.

Anyhow, Susan Barnes-Gelt and I did get off a few good gibes in our "Head On" exchange about '09's nutty possibilities, currently airing on Channel 12 in Denver and elsewhere across the state. Here's the script:

John: It’s time again for Susan and John’s fearless New Year's predictions. 2009 is gonna be crazy. Harry Reid launches a deodorant brand. Jon Stewart and Joe Biden trade jobs. Bill Ritter gives up the governor gig and heads back to Africa as a missionary. Colorado Public Television acquires the Rocky.

Susan: Republicans drown Grover Norquist in a bathtub. Sarah Palin replaces Shawn Hannity and Bill O'Reilly on Fox News, as the station struggles for viewers. Bill Clinton's handicap falls to the single digits as he's banished to the links for the next four years.

John: The Secretary of State’s husband will still have an ethical handicap in triple digits. So Hillary dumps Bill and marries Henry Kissinger. The Onion acquires the New York Times. Mattel acquires GM. The Mafia acquires Chicago. The Obamas get a pretty little pitbull and name it Sarah.

Susan: Hickenlooper goes to Washington to head the Department of Special Events - the perfect job for a guy who is better at putting on a show than governing a city. With DC becoming the nation's new financial hub, Pennsylvania Avenue changes its name to Wall Street and the bankers morph to street sweepers.

Readers poll: Who was great in 2008?

Backbone Americans far prefer Palin or Bush over Time's Person of the Year, Barack Obama. Voting continues, just a click away. Out of a wide-ranging list of nominees from our thousands of friends, Gov. Sarah Palin leads all contenders for Woman of the Year. President George W. Bush is the other top vote-getter for Man of the Year so far.

To vote, click here and use the comment block. Balloting closes 1/4/09.

The wide interests and lively imagination of Backbone Americans are evidenced by the ever-growing breadth of our list. Other nominees receiving multiple votes (shown alphabetically, not by ranking) included:

Armed Forces Personnel Douglas Bruce Dick Cheney Vaclav Klaus Ron Paul David Petraeus Police & Firefighters Alexander Solzhenitsyn Robert Spencer Rick Warren

Single votes have also been cast for the following:

Chuck Baldwin William F. Buckley Jim Bunning Saxby Chambliss Tom Coburn Constitution & Bill of Rights Dinesh D’Souza Anthony Flew Fernando Flores Bobby Jindal Mort Marks John McCain Millennial Generation Albert Mohler Paul Newman Henry Paulson Putin & Medvedev Ronald Reagan Natan Sharansky Tony Snow Tom Tancredo Peter Wallison John Walsh Oprah Winfrey