Captives of the media?

(Denver Post, Jan. 18) You, a captive of the media? No way. Nobody mediates for you. You think independently. You gather your own information and decide for yourself. Me too. We don’t need no media mediating for us, no sir. Yeah, right. In our dreams, maybe, but not in America today. The world is so interconnected, changes so fast, and presents each person with so many choices, that reliance on others for much of our knowledge is inescapable. But which media can we trust, and how do we keep them at our service – on tap, not on top? Especially if newspapers as we have known them are on the way out, how can we stay reliably informed as free citizens in a free society? That’s the underlying concern as Coloradans wonder about the fate of the Rocky Mountain News, Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times, New York Times, and maybe even the Denver Post.

I love newspapers. They’ll always be my preferred window on our civic and cultural life. Online and broadcast media rank a distant second. I hope enough American papers manage to reinvent themselves for the digital era so that print journalism can long continue. Since you’re reading this, you probably agree.

Yet trouble and transformation are stalking the media industry regardless. News providers face brutal pressures to adapt. For us as news users, this is a good time to think about the fundamental question we began with: Who mediates for you? Or as the counter-culture used to say, what do you feed your head?

The media seldom challenge us on this. They have a commercial motive not to. Challenging myself, I find I’m often careless as to both the quality and quantity of what gets fed into my head. New technologies and rebranding by the providers are beside the point. The problem is my passivity about the content they deliver.

A medium is a just a conveyor belt. At one end is a loadmaster, the editor. According to what’s on his clipboard, the belt gets loaded with news from reporters, opinions from pundits, and ads from businesses. It’s all conveniently brought to our homes. That convenience can be a trap, however. We may become too accepting.

“Couldn’t drink coffee without the morning paper,” worried someone at our Vanguard discussion club when the industry’s woes were this month’s topic. “We are Colorado,” says a Denver Post promo campaign. Media companies, this paper included, become part of our lives. They’re still only companies, means to an end. The end is knowing what we need to know to live together responsibly and happily.

Running the conveyor costs money. Persuading us to buy things, either subscriptions or advertised goods and services, is life and death to the company. Print is in trouble because more and more people are buying elsewhere. How concerning is that?

After all, as the Post’s Dean Singleton told fellow publishers in a speech last June, “Newspapers are the cornerstone of democracies everywhere…. If we fail, democracy fails.” Thomas Jefferson said two centuries ago that he’d rather live in a country with newspapers and no government than vice versa. So are bankrupt papers a national crisis?

No. Both men’s points go to freedom of the press via whatever medium works best. They aren’t limited to ink on pulp. In America, thanks to the First Amendment, it’s the marketplace and not government that picks media winners and losers. You and I as consumers, voting with dollars, make that sovereign choice.

Again, as I’ve written before, it’s up to us. Insisting on liberty, WE can make our country’s broadcasting and Internet as free as print has always been. Exercising personal responsibility, WE can choose a healthier information diet, more fiber, less junk. Conveyors inevitably come and go, but independent thinking remains.

Farewell to a president

George W. Bush gave his farewell address to the nation last night.  I thank him for his service. And in some important ways I will miss him.

Yes, there is plenty for conservatives to lament about his presidency. He presided over an unprecedented expansion of government pork and failed at every turn to rein in the profligate spenders in Congress. From 2001 to 2006 he presided over a unified government where the opportunities for driving home small-government conservatism were everywhere. But, alas, George W. Bush proved himself to be a big government conservative instead – failing to veto a single bill spending until 2006 (after the Democrats took control) and allowing a vast expansion of Medicare entitlements under his watch. Clearly, George Bush is no Ronald Reagan.

But it is equally clear to me that after 9/11, George Bush made a deal with himself and the nation: he would work tirelessly to keep us safe, even if he had to make compromises with Congress on spending and the economy. For as painful as the recent economic meltdown is, it is not fatal. 9/11 put this presidency on a wartime footing and in war you sometime make deals with the devil. FDR, the president the left likes to prominently stand up as the ideal Democrat, interned thousands of Japanese Americans in the name of national security.

War isn’t pretty. It requires lots of compromises in both policy and practice, and sometimes you have to do things that you don't want to do. One guesses that Barack Obama will soon see how tough this is.

So, George Bush decided that to keep Congress in line on fighting Al Qaeda and taking out Saddam Hussein, he would allow all sorts of domestic shenanigans. And this included looking the other way as the risks associated with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac escalated, fueling the sub-prime mortgage mess that exploded late in the 2008 campaign. Yes, there were warning signs galore – the collapse of Bear Stearns, the puncturing of the housing bubble, the government’s own internal audits.

But it hardly mattered to this war president: By 2006, with Iraq in disarray and verging on catastrophic failure, the president was focused exclusively outward. The slow fires burning at home were nagging problems that could hardly compare to the challenges of war in the Mid East. Bush – nor anyone else – could have predicted the massive crisis that has ensnared the world economy.

This, of course, doesn’t give the President a pass. Hardly. His failure to create and sustain a clear philosophy on economic matters helped to ensure that the storm that hit the financial markets would be stronger and more sustained than it ordinarily might have been. He was derelict in his leadership, of that there is no question – and history will judge him so.

But I give the man ample credit for trying to change the balance of power in the Middle East and in keeping the homeland safe from attack. No one on 9/12/2001 would have bet that Al Qaeda would not attack again and soon. His strength and unwavering discipline to do “what is necessary” to keep America safe is something that he will be lauded for in years to come. And his courage to take out Saddam and create a democracy in Iraq has the chance to remake the Arabian peninsula for years to come.  And while he has failed to confront Iran with sufficient force, the opportunity to make Iraq into an ally in the region should provide a useful base from which to both oppose Iran and support Israel.  Iraq -- if successful and intelligently utilized -- can provide a critical "balance shifter" in the fight against Shia extremism.

Time will tell if the Obama administration will risk or reward this grand effort.

In the end, my guess is that George W. Bush will be kindly remembered by historians, though like Truman, it may take a generation or two for it to happen. The long-term impact of Iraq and the overall war on terror will not quickly be clear. But when it is, he will get much credit for seeing evil and trying to defeat it.

We can only hope that his successor has such clarity.

State Senate & House contact info

Colorado's citizen legislature, with session limits, lean staffing, and offices in the Capitol itself, enhances accessibility for you and me. Following up our Jan. 15 radio special, "Under the Dome: Legislative Preview 2009," here's a quick reference for Democrat and Republican leaders in this year's General Assembly. It meets until early May.

Senate President: Sen. Peter Groff 303-866-3342, peter.groff.senate@state.co.us

Senate President Pro Tem: Sen. Betty Boyd 303-866-4857, betty.boyd.senate@state.co.us

Senate Majority Leader: Sen. Brandon Shaffer 303-866-5291, brandon.shaffer.senate@state.co.us

Senate Minority Leader: Sen. Josh Penry 303-866-3077, joshpenry@gmail.com

Senate Asst. Minority Leader: Sen. Greg Brophy 303-866-6360, greg@gregbrophy.net

====================================

Speaker of the House: Rep. Terrance Carroll 303-866-2909, terrance.carroll.house@state.co.us

Speaker Pro Tem: Rep. Kathleen Curry 303-866-2945, repcurry@gmail.com

House Majority Leader: Rep. Paul Weissmann 303-866-2920, reppaul@aol.com

House Minority Leader: Rep. Mike May 303-866-5523, mike.may.house@state.co.us

House Asst. Minority Leader: Rep. David Balmer 303-866-2935, david.balmer.house@state.co.us

=====================================

A full directory of all 100 members, committee assignments, and status of bills, is online at www.leg.state.co.us.

AFP holds line in '09 for Colo. taxpayer

I listened to Gov. Bill Ritter's State of the State speech with anticipation the other day, and we have reason to be concerned. According to the Governor, we need to "invest...despite these tough economic times", and get rid of spending and tax limitations which the Taxpayers Bill of Rights [TABOR] has effectively secured. Ritter wants to extend the spending increases of Referendum C from 2005 and continue seeking changes in TABOR's limitations on taxing and spending. Here’s a quote from his speech:

"As I’ve said before, a budget is a moral document that should reflect our values. . . . There is also an opportunity here – a chance to address TABOR and the constitutional and statutory straitjacket that makes modern, sensible and value-based budgeting an impossibility."

The Governor, though, has left some questions unasked in this statement. Whose values determine what a “sensible” budget is? I know for most Colorado families, a sensible budget is the smallest one possible where they can meet their monthly needs. If their income suddenly decreases or they can't keep up with their credit card payments. Something has to give. They are forced to cut back their spending. Is this the value-based approach to budgeting the Governor finds “sensible”? Or is the “straightjacket” of TABOR, as he implies, keeping him from spending more of our money.

He argues that we have many challenges ahead, but he proposes get rid of TABOR to deal with them. He hopes to remove TABOR's restraints so that he can build a "modern" (read: bloated) government. It seems to be a pattern we are following all over the country: in times of crisis, turn to government for help. Of course, Colorado is faring much better than other states like California which are begging the Congress to bail them out. And TABOR has played a big part in keeping us from going into the tank like they have when huge budgets meet decreasing tax revenues in these tough times.

Americans for Prosperity is going to continue the fight to make this case publicly with your help. When citizens come out in a show of force like they did for us last year, it sends a message to our politicians that we Coloradans will not accept an ever increasing government.

What is a modern budget, Governor Ritter? Does that include ever increasing spending and expanding government services? Or are there some limits to the amount of government we need? Governor Ritter said that when he and other Governors met with Senator Obama in November, the President-elect said, “. . . it would take courage and a strong federal-state partnership to get America back on the path to long-term prosperity.” When has a federal-state government partnership ever made us more prosperous? Does government bring prosperity or do the people and their spirit of ingenuity? These are the questions advocates of government action never seem to ask.

Our left-leaning Congress and State General Assembly will attempt to push the limits expanding government’s role in our economy. Unfortunately, that's what Republicans did when they had the Congress and paid the price at the ballot box. You can be assured that we will oppose any changes to TABOR and any further expansion of government spending beyond the limits imposed by TABOR whether proposed by Republicans or Democrats. But we will need your help to put pressure on our elected representatives to hold the line on spending.

First of all, AFP is hoping for the grassroots army which came out last year to our Hot Air Balloon and Town Hall events to come out again this year to State House rallies and Town Hall events as we force our elected officials to see that Coloradans do not support expanded government.

I am asking for your help if we are going to be successful at stopping the Governor’s and the legislature’s efforts to eliminate TABOR. If TABOR goes down, it would give them the ammunition they need to increase spending and taxes to pay for their pet projects without the “hassle” of obtaining a vote of the people. Please support Americans for Prosperity so we can remain an active, effective force for less government in Colorado.

Last year, Coloradans defeated five measures which would have increased taxes and government spending by nearly $350 million. There is a force of people in Colorado like you who believe in free markets and responsible government.

I look forward to working with you as we continue to hold the line on TABOR and take a strong stand for our rights as citizens of Colorado.

Jim Pfaff is Colorado director for Americans for Prosperity. See www.afphq.org.