Teacher's Desk: CSAP SNAFU

Running for a seat on the Colorado Board of Education almost two decades ago, I championed the idea of an accountability test. Little did I know I would later be suffering the angst of giving such a test. This CSAP was not what I had in mind. I was of the mindset that we give a test to measure students’ performance of Colorado academic standards that was simple, easy-to-take, easy-to-assess, and inexpensive like an Iowa, California, or ACT. Today, as site assessment leader at our school, I arrange and train proctors, keep all the different tests organized, and proctor make-up after make-up after make-up tests. The students required to take the CSAP are our recently enrolled students who generally have poor attendance, poor skills, and even poorer attitudes. Fortunately, that is usually less than 30 students for day and night school! Proctoring make-up tests takes away the planning period of two teachers and the attention of our discipline coach (dean).

Larger high schools and middle schools do wonderful give-a-ways of I-pods, video games, flat screen televisions, and gift certificates. Students are usually given a number for a drawing after each test they take. For 8th and 10th graders, that is approximately twelve hours of testing! Even though many of these students are not used to making good choices, many of them show up for every test and try to do their best. Recently, the legislature looked at forbidding schools from using incentives.

The original purpose of this test was to make schools accountable to their communities and taxpayers, as well as, compare schools’ results so that parents could make better school choices. I don’t disagree with that. There were plenty of schools in poor neighborhoods that were making excuses instead of doing the job the taxpayers were paying them to do: educate every child, no matter the child’s circumstance. I do think it is time to find a more efficient method of assessing student progress by using a simpler, less expensive assessment tool aligned with our state standards.

In March 4th’s Denver Post, www.denverpost.com/breakingnews/ci_11830285, parents at Hanson Pre-K through 8 school are using the CSAP as a weapon. They want the district to return their school, the lowest performing school in the district, to a bi-lingual approach and reinstate their beloved principal, even though objective assessments inform us the bi-lingual format is not improving student performance. By holding the school “hostage,” the school’s aggregate scores will be even lower and places the school at-risk for closure.

Instead, if the parents want a bi-lingual approach to their students’ education, and they feel their desires are ignored, they should develop their own charter school that is designed to support a bi-lingual environment. There are several schools, mostly charter schools, that take a bi-lingual or even multi-lingual approach. The Colorado League of Charter Schools and Colorado Department of Education are great resources for start-up charter schools.

Governor Ritter’s P-20 panel wants Colorado to take another look at state accountability tests, especially at the high school level. That makes sense to me, as long as there continues to be transparent accountability of student achievement.

Kathleen Kullback is a special educator with an MA in educational leadership and is a former candidate for the Colorado State Board of Education.

Sinister squeeze on faith-based campuses

I walked into the cafeteria here at Colorado Christian University, pondering what Obama meant last week when he called for higher education for everyone. I then sat down with a colleague from CCU's development office. He asked me what I thought of Obama's plan to limit charitable giving.

Suddenly I started to put two and two together. I am convinced that Obama wants to squeeze schools like CCU out of existence. If he offers tuition-free higher ed, it won't be to schools like ours. Then if he hinders our donor base, it will be a one-two punch to our viability.

Then if he limits freedom of speech with the "Fairness Doctrine".... And socializes medicine... Obama wants to control education, the media, even our healthcare.

Some fear that we are moving inexorably toward a totalitarian regime. Are they overreacting?

William Watson is professor of modern history at Colorado Christian University in Lakewood.

Five world flashpoints confront Obama

(Washington, Mar. 1) While it seems strange to be hailing the prophetic gifts of Joe Biden, his prediction last fall about very serious foreign policy challenges to a President Obama within six months of his inauguration retrospectively appears as one of the most astute and honest insights of the election year. While the buzz in this company town remains dominated by Democratic self-congratulation over their world historical spending spree there is yet detectable an underlying apprehension that further socialist triumphs could be jeopardized by unanticipated eruptions on the international front.

Let us glance quickly at five areas of potential crisis in ascending order of probable importance. North Korea, Russia, Mexico, Israel and, worst of all, Afghanistan head the list of places where Biden's prophecy could soon come true.

Hillary Clinton’s recent visit to the Far East brought renewed attention to continuing instability in the Korean peninsula. The indefensible Bush blunder of formally removing North Korea from the list of terror-sponsoring nations against all evidence and in return for absolutely nothing gravely disturbed Japanese-American relations, validated the blackmailing policies of Kim Jong-I L, and sent strong signals of American inconstancy and indecisiveness throughout the region.

Copying a play patented by fellow nuclear wannabe Iran, North Korea recently announced that its’ “Space Program” would soon be testing a new rocket that incidentally has the capacity to reach the West Coast of the United States. Secretary Clinton boldly described this move as “unhelpful”.

As President Obama has his first personal encounters with Western European leaders a major topic will be how to deal with the ever feisty Vladimir Putin. Currently the Obama Administration is “studying” the Bush promise to install an SDI-like missile defense shield in Poland and the Czech Republic. The result of this evaluation will tell all of East Central Europe, particularly Ukraine, the extent of their “aloneness” vis a vis their former masters in the Kremlin.

In general beyond “feeling their love” President Obama will find that regarding increased military assistance in Afghanistan and elsewhere, the NATO allies aren’t going to do anymore for him than they did for George Bush- probably even less considering their withdrawal timetables on current troop commitments and their continually shrinking defense budgets.

When a recent National Intelligence Estimate declared Mexico to be in a flat footed tie with Pakistan as the world’s leading candidate for “Failed Nation” status, America was suddenly awakened to the fact that things haven’t been going swimmingly for our amigos south of the border. In a bizarre act of collective non-attention the U.S. media paid almost no heed to thousands of assassinations (including many spectacular beheadings), nonstop violence by drug cartels who effectively rule large parts of the country, the total ineffectiveness of the corrupted National Police and the recent calling out of the Army to regain control of certain provinces along the U.S. border. Even worse, multi-billion dollar drug smuggling into the U.S. has caused a wave of violence to spill hugely across our borders. Today Phoenix has the second highest kidnapping rate of any city in the world.

In the Middle East the post-election emergence of Benjamin Netanyahu as leader of a very hawkish Israeli government dashes the hopes of the Obama Administration for advancing the endlessly fruitless “Peace Process”.

While Netanyahu will bide his time pending talks with Obama and the Iranian elections in June virtually all Israelis have been persuaded by the 7,000 rockets that landed on their country that talking to the Palestinians is useless until Iran’s proxy Hamas is destroyed.

Finally the number one foreign challenge for President Obama is clearly Afghanistan. In a masterful political sleight of hand during the campaign Obama demonstrated his toughness by defining Afghanistan as the “Right War” that he would “win”, while Iraq was the “Wrong War” that George Bush had “lost”. It would be a supreme irony if in the end History records Bush as the “Victor of Iraq” and Obama as the man who had “lost” Afghanistan ( and Pakistan as well).

A recent USA Today story on Afghanistan was titled “Obama’s War”. That story and several others have noted that the anti-war passions that have been the hallmark of the Democratic Party for over forty years are already rising. The exceedingly low key announcement of 17,000 more troops going to Afghanistan and the ongoing “strategic re-evaluation” suggest that the President is very aware of his dilemma.

As the world watches the Obama Drama continues to unfold.

William Moloney’s columns have appeared in the Wall St. Journal, USA Today, Washington Post, Washington Times, Philadelphia Inquirer, Baltimore Sun, Denver Post, and Rocky Mountain News.

Principle, expediency & the Republicans

A handful of GOP governors, including Jindal of Louisiana and Sanford of South Carolina, are taking a courageous stand against the stimulus. Pressed with the threat of amending welfare laws in their states for years to come and violating the principles of good governance made this nation great, these governors are refusing to accept funding for new unemployment benefits, much to the chagrin of their Democratic counterparts. "This to me is not about philosophical theory, [but] about real people who through no fault of their own, are laid off because of a recession," argued Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm on "FOX News Sunday" this past weekend.

Apparently Republican stances, based largely on core beliefs but even transcending them into the realm of good governance, particularly the issue of the dangers it sets for future welfare programs in their states, are inappropriate in a time of “crisis.”

This, Governor Granholm, isn’t just about philosophical theory, though that is certainly important. It is also about the people—“real people.” Consider: Three years from now, when federal funding dries up and the states are stuck with these laws, how are higher taxes to make up the difference going to help the people? When Dick and Jane decide to stay on welfare for five years instead of two, how is that helping to get them moving and making better lives for themselves, their family and their community?

The answer is, it’s not. Principles may be driving these stands, but underlying each principled governor is justified concern for the future of their state. They’re doing what leaders should be doing: looking toward the impact of their present decisions on the future, not just the effect of those decisions on the now.

Of course, while America’s greatest national interest has been at stake—its security—the Democrats had no problem crying “principle” and putting “philosophical theory” over effective interrogation procedures. But when their own political interests in appearing to be strong, firm leaders are being threatened, and their own agendas to expand government in unprecedented ways are on the line, they have no problem throwing principle out the window.

Terrorism is a different issue; most of the actions that were taken on the part of U.S. interrogators were not, in actuality, torture. Contrary to popular misconception, waterboarding has only been used three times—and in each of those three times it worked, and innumerable lives were saved. Early on some cases were questionable, such as Abu Graihb and early Guantanamo Bay practices, but by and large principle did guide the nation’s interrogation policy.

On the issue of warrantless wiretapping, the government was not wiretapping every phone in America without a warrant, converse to ACLU misinformation. Rather, if Abdul’s conversations are being monitored in Pakistan and he calls Ahmed in the United States, is the government supposed to put down the phone and say, “Oops, American citizen?” Of course not, and that’s what the policy ensured. Yet the Democrats made a big fuss about how this violated the “rights of the citizen.” They cried “principle,” yet none were actually violated.

But now the tide has turned and the Democrats are the one whose policies are being challenged. Their reckless willingness to throw up their hands and truly abandon our ideals is troublesome at best. If we can just casually say, whenever a new crisis arises, that principle is irrelevant, what will we have left? Can we pick and choose when to let core beliefs be our guide and when to ignore them?

Far too many leaders have given the same argument—we’re in a crisis, so let’s set aside our core beliefs. Such is the true test of leadership. Will our leaders stand by those convictions in troubled times, or will they set them aside because of the perceived ease in doing so?

If we refuse to allow our conscience of principle to be our guide in crisis, instead only permitting its surface in pleasant times, our ideals are rendered meaningless.

Thomas Jefferson’s statement that his “reading of history convinces [him] that most bad government results from too much government” no longer holds any meaning for the Democrats, as well as Republicans like Governors Charlie Crist and Arnold Schwarzenegger. That is, if it ever has.

“The spirit of resistance to government,” Jefferson once said, “is so valuable on certain occasions that I wish it to be always kept alive.”

One can only hope that more governors will have the courage to stand up and resist the temptation to cede more power and authority to government. The future of this country may depend on it.